The ACLU welcomed Gonazales participation, particularly since former AG John Ashcroft refused to meet with the group during his tenure. ACLU Executive Director Anthony Romero says:

"It's a positive step to have an attorney general willing to engage the ACLU in a frank discussion of this controversial, problematic legislation," Romero said. "However, the real proof of whether we have a different Justice Department will be in what changes to the Patriot Act they are willing to offer and accept."

"Mr. Gonzales expressed an understanding that the administration's lack of transparency and failure to engage its critics have contributed to growing, bipartisan concerns. Most importantly, Mr. Gonzales signaled a willingness to consider changes to portions of the Patriot Act. We look forward to working with the attorney general -- and with the growing list of Republicans and conservative organizations that call for Patriot Act reforms -- to bring the legislation in line with the Constitution."

Details about constitutional problems with the Patriot Act are available on the ACLU's website here.