home

Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die

I almost threw up my lunch when I saw this.

Not a dime today, not a dollar tomorrow. We'll be boycotting Bali until the Indonesian courts set Schapelle Corby free.

Note: the signs are in English. Why? The trial was conducted in Indonesian. The two hour verdict was read in Indonesian. Schapelle had to listen to her fate as a translater haltingly related only portions of it, because the judges were screaming so loud and talking so fast no one could humanly perform simultaneous translation. The prison guards and inmates don't speak English. This was a ploy by some fascist group for media attention. We're happy to oblige and expose their barbarism.

Would I let my kid visit Bali? Over my dead body.

If you need another reason to cancel your trip to Indonesia, consider that the U.S. and Australia have warned in recent days that real terrorists (not Schapelle Corby supporters) have promised an attack on Jakarta hotels in early June.

Update: At least one snarky Indonesian columnist would welcome the boycott.

Indonesians shouldn't be upset either about Australians boycotting Bali. Giving the island a bit of a break from rowdy backpackers is not necessarily a bad thing. On the contrary, it would give more room for those nouveaux riches from mainland China and Taiwan who actually seem to enjoy spending their dollars more than sunbathing on the beach, or for the real Europeans from the West who display by far better appreciation of the local culture and possessing finer sensibilities than their more uncouth counterparts from down under.

This letter to the editor of the Jakarta Post lays out some of the failings of the Indonesian legal system and the Australian Government in Schapelle's case.

Many Aussies are upset about the way the Corby trial has progressed, but that anger is as much about our government's handling of the case as it is about Indonesia's judiciary. Our federal police chief sent a letter to the court stating that there was no corruption at our airports, a fact that has been found to be totally false. Check-in film and baggage weight information was not made available; no baggage handlers have been interviewed and no expert legal counsel was made available to Corby's defense team until the very last minute.

Another matter that worries Australians is Bali's judicial system. The police did not fingerprint the bag, they did not check for the origin of the cannabis, they did not film the opening of the bags. And why they did not look into possible baggage tampering at the Bali airport? The prosecution boasted publicly that they only prosecuted guilty people.

Where is the presumption of innocence?

And why, as the writer asks, is there no transcript of the shout fest that was the verdict, "so anyone can look at all the evidence and the background to the verdict at a later date?"

< Air Force Academy: We Have No Respect | A Pastry Chef's Questions About Torture in America >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#2)
    by Andreas on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    A demonstration of 40 right wing extremists in Jakarta is a pretty weak argument to support a call for a boycott of Bali.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#3)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    Andreas, it's more just added reasons for those I've given before.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#4)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    Opinionated, TalkLeft often highlights the plight of those in foreign prison, particularly those facing the death penalty. See these posts on Tripoli; Vietnam; and Saudi Arabia, to name a few. Last week I wrote about a Phillipine painter who was sentenced to life in prison for selling 0.02 grams of Shabu. TalkLeft often highlights actual and possible innocence cases of those of all races and nationalities. Click here. Why does it have to be part of a long-standing campaign? I just learned that Indonesia sentences people to life and possibly the death penalty for for pot offenses - so mine is a new-standing campaign to raise awareness about the Indonesian legal system and urge people to avoid going there, particularly since it appears there is a crime ring going on involving baggage handlers that could result in someone being framed. I also have been highlighting the plight of the Bali 9, who are young kids facing the death penalty for heroin smuggling into Bali. Kids often don't consider consequences. To make 18 and 19 year olds pay with their life for what might be a one-time mistake in judgment is not right. If kids stay away from Bali, innocent or guilty, it won't happen to them.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#5)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    I've already been boycotting Indonesia long before this debacle ever came about. Their repressive laws in general are totally draconian, and it's really such a shame that one of the most scenically breathtaking places on earth is run by such a horribly backward lot.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#6)
    by Che's Lounge on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    And we still help them. Despite an embargo, we still train their "security forces". Contracted out. Doo dah, Doo dah. Heck, their president is a US trained general! Just like Iraq in the 80's. As long as they're not TOO repressive.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#7)
    by unbill on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    Thanks for the coverage on this issue. I am also disturbed, though, of your use of language. Your statement about their being neanderthals bothered me a bit, being that Indonesia is a rather modern authoritarian state. In that sense, I wouldn't use the term "neanderthals", nor would I discuss the purported "barbarism" there. But, I definitely understand the dismay behind your words. It seems as if the most important thing to do would be to politicize the problems surrounding the Indonesian political and criminal system in general. It would also be important to ask why the United States government has supported Indonesia for decades and why it continues to do so. Unfortunately, the current answer seems to be clear: Indonesia has been more than willing to go along with the US-led international wars on drugs and terror. Indonesia is definitely a case of the USA supporting a criminal regime for its own gain. The Bush administration should be taken to task on this one.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#8)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    I want to echo Opinionated Lawyer, but I also want to disagree with them. By all means demonstrate against the Jakarta government, boycott them, and so on. They need to know that there is an issue here, that their actions have consequences and that people are watching. The Balinese are being pushed around here, as much as are white Australians. But an equal target of action should be the Australian government. They are responsible for security at Sydney, which seems to be scandalous, and which undermines confidence in the safety of the national airline Qantas. Preserving Qantas' safety reputation is a fetish with Australians and it is not hard to imagine that this is what is going on here. I could also ask whether the Labor opposition is more concerned with maintaining airport employment practices than it is with supporting Corby. But ask the Howard government if its immigration practices, its treatment of Indonesians and its involvement in the Iraq war haven't brought this about by giving the Javanese a target at whom to strike back. Demonstrations, no matter at whom they are targeted, only really affect one's own government. (Boycotts are another matter). So demonstrating against Indonesia in Australia would be to pressure the Howard government anyway. But it has to be articulated to Howard that it is his job to fix this.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#9)
    by scarshapedstar on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    Amy, the trial was a sham.

    Andreas, you mentioned in a comment that 40 right-wing protestors was not enough to justify a boycott. While they are among a myriad of reasons to boycott, they alone are a very disturbing sight. Any nation in which even ultra right-wing followers, who are always extreme, can feel justified in calling for death based on possession of a drug is due for a change of opinion at least, or a healthy paradigm-shift at most.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#11)
    by DawesFred60 on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:41 PM EST
    See people didn't i tell you this would happen, the people in that part of the world hate people like her and want her dead ASP! And the people in that part of the world love Bin Laden and would love to kill you, this poor woman i do cry for and the millions that will follow her into a black hell to come. free this woman. sadly she will be killed after a long torture, within 6 months.

    They should free the killers involved in the Bali massacre, too. Crucify Her Crucify Her Crucify Her.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#13)
    by Aaron on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:42 PM EST
    While I support your exposure of this issue, the injustice which this one person is receiving, it's not even a drop in the bucket beside the injustices which go on and daily around the globe. [remainder deleted. This thread is about Schapelle Corby.]

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#14)
    by Andreas on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:42 PM EST
    I will reformulate the "diplomatic" language I used above. A demonstration of 40 right wing extremists is no argument to support a call for a boycott anywhere. The headline ("Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die") makes it obvious that the Indonesian people are blamed for those activities. The 40 demonstrators in Jakarta are less representative for the Indonesian people than the war criminal George W. Bush and the fascists and gangsters who support his regime are representative for the American people.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#15)
    by Richard Aubrey on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:42 PM EST
    off topic comment deleted

    This thread is about Schapelle Corby. Off topic comments will be deleted.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#17)
    by DawesFred60 on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:43 PM EST
    Oh yes write to her and tell her we all know about her case, and tell her we do care about the others inside that hell called priosns all over the world. Free this casualty of the drug war.

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#18)
    by SeeEmDee on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:44 PM EST
    Before any more rancorous words are said, it might help to ask a few questions: What were Indonesia's drug laws like before it began accepting US and foreign aid? What changes in Indonesia's drug laws took place after receiving that aid? The answers to those two questions might explain Indonesia's attitude towards Corby.

    Plus the other dilemma - if a foreign national was convicted of a capital crime in America (let's say an illegal Mexican rapes and murders a Southern blossom), and only got 20 years, wouldn't Americans be marching in the streets too?

    Re: Indonesians March for Schapelle Corby to Die (none / 0) (#20)
    by kdog on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 12:59:44 PM EST
    The death penalty for pot is in the same ballpark as a 25 year sentence. I wholeheartedly agree w/ the boycott, but we could add a slew of countries to the boycott, including our own. Chaining and caging human beings over plants is barbaric insanity, plain and simple.

    Blagh agrees, but Americans (and Canadians) are very quick to point out how "foreigners" are ruining their social fabric (throw in most of Europe too)...seems to me (and forgive Blagh for the first-person usage) that alot of white people (including liberals, in fact some of the worst offenders) are very content portraying brown people as "victims," until those brown people rise up and "make their own laws and have their own rules," and then the world is ending...Westerners have been unjustly convicting and imprisoning brown people since they learned how to differentiate colors...now it's a shame...please... Blagh feels for Schapelle, but seriously, how many brown people around the world have been killed or maimed by "white" foreign policy as these words were being keyed in? Aside from their families, who's crying for them? Blagh ain't agreeing with the Balinese, but he knows where they're coming from...and so do a few of you...