home

Matthew Cooper: Rove Said, ' I' ve Already Said Too Much'

Update: Today's Meet the Press transcript of Cooper is here. Video up shortly on Crooks and Liars here.

Matthew Cooper's Time Magazine article is out on his recollection of his call with Karl Rove. [The free press release with many details is here. The full article is subscription only so I will outline first what's in the press release, and then, other items in the full article.

First, from the press release:

Cooper writes in this week’s issue that he testified that, although it’s not reflected in his notes or subsequent emails, he had a distinct memory of Rove ending the call by saying, “I’ve already said too much.” Cooper writes this could have meant he was worried about being indiscreet or just late for a meeting or something else. “I don’t know, but that sign-off has been in my memory for two years,” Cooper writes.

Cooper writes that special counsel Patrick Fitzgerald “asked me several different ways if Rove indicated how he had heard that (Valerie) Plame worked at the CIA.” Cooper says he testified that Rove did not.

Cooper was asked about his conversation with Libby and said Libby, like Rove, said something like "I've heard that too."

Cooper writes that, like Rove, Libby never used Plame’s name or indicated that her status was covert and he never told Cooper that he had heard about Plame from other reporters, as some press accounts have indicated. On background, Cooper had asked Libby if he had heard anything about Wilson’s wife sending him to Niger. Libby answered with words to the effect of “Yeah, I’ve heard that too.”

Cooper says the grand jurors, mostly African American women had more questions than Fitzgerald. Grand jurors can ask questions through the prosecutor.

Other items of note from the full article:

  • " Virtually all the questions centered on the week of July 6, 2003."
  • The grand jurors wanted to know what on Cooper's mind:

I was interested in an ancillary question about why government officials, publicly and privately, seemed to be disparaging Wilson. It struck me, as I told the grand jury, as odd and unnecessary, especially after their saying the President's address should not have included the 16-word claim about Saddam and African uranium. I told the grand jurors that I was curious about Wilson when I called Karl Rove on Friday, July 11.

  • Karl Rove was a focus of their questions:

As I told the grand jury--and we went over this in microscopic, excruciating detail, which may someday prove relevant--I recall calling Rove from my office at TIME magazine through the White House switchboard and being transferred to his office. I believe a woman answered the phone and said words to the effect that Rove wasn't there or was busy before going on vacation. But then, I recall, she said something like, "Hang on," and I was transferred to him. I recall saying something like, "I'm writing about Wilson," before he interjected. "Don't get too far out on Wilson," he told me. I started taking notes on my computer, and while an e-mail I sent moments after the call has been leaked, my notes have not been.

  • The grand jury asked about the meaning of "double secret background." Cooper says it was his own term, which he got from the movie Animal House.

In fact, I told the grand jury, Rove told me the conversation was on "deep background." I explained to the grand jury that I take the term to mean that I can use the material but not quote it, and that I must keep the identity of my source confidential.

  • Cooper told the grand jury both Rove and Libby denied that Cheney had sent Wilson to Niger.

Rove went on to say that Wilson had not been sent to Niger by the director of the CIA and, I believe from my subsequent e-mails--although it's not in my notes--that Rove added that Dick Cheney didn't send him either. Indeed, the next day the Vice President's chief of staff, I. Lewis (Scooter) Libby, told me Cheney had not been responsible for Wilson's mission.

  • The grand jurors asked questions about his notes:

There were some words in my notes that I could not account for--at one point they read, "...notable..." I didn't know if that was Rove's word or mine, and one grand juror asked if it might mean "not able," as in "Wilson was not an able person." I said that was possible, but I just didn't recall that. The notes, and my subsequent e-mails, go on to indicate that Rove told me material was going to be declassified in the coming days that would cast doubt on Wilson's mission and his findings.

  • Cooper speculates as to what Fitzgerald may be after:

He asked me several different ways if Rove indicated how he had heard that Plame worked at the CIA. (He did not, I told the grand jury.) Maybe Fitzgerald is interested in whether Rove knew her CIA ties through a person or through a document.

  • Cooper was asked in detail if he discussed welfare reform with Karl Rove. He doesn't remember doing so in that call, although he had been working on that at the time.

Rove's lawyer, Robert Luskin, had told journalists that when I telephoned Rove that July, it was about welfare reform and that I suddenly switched topics to the Wilson matter....To me this suggested that Rove may have testified that we had talked about welfare reform, and indeed earlier in the week, I may have left a message with his office asking if I could talk to him about welfare reform. But I can't find any record of talking about it with him on July 11, and I don't recall doing so.

  • Cooper's conclusion:

So did Rove leak Plame's name to me, or tell me she was covert? No. Was it through my conversation with Rove that I learned for the first time that Wilson's wife worked at the CIA and may have been responsible for sending him? Yes. Did Rove say that she worked at the "agency" on "WMD"? Yes. When he said things would be declassified soon, was that itself impermissible? I don't know. Is any of this a crime? Beats me. At this point, I'm as curious as anyone else to see what Patrick Fitzgerald has.

Afterthought: From REM's Losing My Religion:

Oh no, I've said too much
I haven't said enough
...Oh no, I've said too much
I set it up

< Chicago Cop Arrested for Murder | Charges Against Saddam Hussein Announced >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    "I've already said too much" from Rove could mean only one thing: "I've said all I needed to say to accomplish my objective." In this case doing the maximum amount of damage to Joe Wilson in revenge of his infidelity to the regime.

    Re: Matthew Cooper: Rove Said, ' I' ve Already Sai (none / 0) (#2)
    by ppjakajim on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 01:01:19 PM EST
    Ernesto - Funny what things mean to different people. To me it only means: Hey, I've given you a heads-up and warning, and I aint gonna say anymore because I've already helped you more than I should. Kinda like: "I know that Suzy went out with Bob and he proposed but she turned him down so you are wrong about them getting married because she wants a guy with money…But I've already said too much.”

    To me it sounds like a pretty contrived effort to make absolutely sure that Wilson's CIA connections got into Cooper's story. If a reporter (and I'm speaking as one) thinks he's gotten someone to say "too much," he thinks he has a leg up on others who might be writing similar stories. I imagine Rove is very familiar with reporter psychology by now, and how best to manipulate it.

    Funny what things mean to different people.
    Perhaps so...but the point is in this case we have only to figure out what they mean in the context of who said it and why...and I think c-law pretty much nailed that part.

    Actually the point about the declassification is very significant. It must refer to the State Dept memo that NYT wrote about. Talon/Ganon mentioned that it was about to be declassified. But Rove said he never saw the memo and was unaware of it. How than can he assure Cooper that a document he is unaware of is about to be declassified.

    Re: Matthew Cooper: Rove Said, ' I' ve Already Sai (none / 0) (#6)
    by scarshapedstar on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 01:01:19 PM EST
    To me it only means: Hey, I've given you a heads-up and warning, and I aint gonna say anymore because I've already helped you more than I should.
    That's nice, but I prefer the standard interpretation of "I'm already putting my neck on the chopping block." Ever wonder what Saint Karl was afraid of, Jim?

    To me it only means: Hey, I've given you a heads-up and warning, and I aint gonna say anymore because I've already helped you more than I should.
    What do you mean that, "I've helped you more than I should?" That doesn't eliminate the suspicious interpretation at all; instead it replaces one suspicious phrase with another one. Anyone who "excuses" his behavior like this knows he's acting wrongly. I'd come clean if I were you.

    Because Karl Rove only exists to help reporters. His record of lying and cheating? Perfect for the job. Hey, here's some nat'l security info you can use to end up in jail. Don't bother thanking me -- just send some money to the RNC if the tip hits big. If you go to jail over receiving classified info, don't forget OMERTA. And have a nice day.

    "I've said too much" only means one thing: I just gave you a hot one, fat boy, now run with it. It is completely, totally unambiguous. Matt Cooper would have to be retarded to mistake Rove's meaning.

    Cooper knew what Rove meant. He was just trying to say something in support of Rove, and that's all he could come up with...understandable.

    Re: Matthew Cooper: Rove Said, ' I' ve Already Sai (none / 0) (#11)
    by john horse on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 01:01:19 PM EST
    Here is part of the question and answer from Cooper's grand jury testimony (via Juan Cole). "Did Rove say that she worked at the `agency' on `WMD'?"--weapons of mass destruction." "Yes." "When he said things would be declassified soon, was that itself impermissible?" "I don't know." At the time Rove spoke to reporter Cooper, he knew he was giving classified information. Whether he thought that it would be "declassified soon" is immaterial. At the time he spoke to the reporter it was classified.