The Talk Line

All About Crime, All the Time

September, 2000

TalkLeft Top News Upcoming Events
Election 2000 News Legislative Updates
Op-Ed Columns TalkLeft Commentary
Investigative Reporting Sound Bytes
Political Cartoons Hot Reads
Talk Line 2000 Archives About TalkLeft

TalkLeft Top News

9/30/2000...Inmates Can Seek DNA Tests, Judge Says ...Washington Post

Inmates who claim they were wrongfully convicted have a right to go to federal court and request DNA testing that might prove their innocence, a federal judge ruled yesterday.

9/30/2000...Texas ACLU Files Suit Over Drug Bust...Associated Press

A lawsuit was filed against two law enforcement agents and a district attorney for their role in an arrest stemming from a much-criticized drug bust that prompted allegations of racial discrimination in 1999.

9/29/2000...Inmates Win on DNA Tests - New Law Sets Right to Procedure...Sacramento Bee

The California governor's approval of SB 1342, offered by Sen. John Burton, D-San Francisco, makes California the sixth state to provide DNA tests to prisoners meeting certain conditions. Davis on Thursday signed two other DNA-related bills, one which allows police to compare a suspect's DNA profile with evidence from unsolved crimes; and another which creates a new DNA database for missing-persons cases.

9/29/2000...Appeals Court To Rehear Weaver Case...Associated Press

A federal appeals court Friday agreed to rehear arguments on whether the FBI sharpshooter who killed Randy Weaver's wife during the 1992 standoff at Ruby Ridge, Idaho, can be prosecuted on manslaughter charges.

9/29/2000...Md. Compiles Bullet Fingerprints...Associated Press

Beginning on Sunday, with every new handgun sold in Maryland, the manufacturer will have to give state police a spent shell casing carrying the weapon's ballistic fingerprint. Under the law -- the first of its kind in the nation -- the unique markings on the casing will then be entered into a database. When detectives find a bullet casing at a crime scene, they can go to the computer and instantly identify the gun it came from.

9/29/2000...Death Sentence Overturned in Texas...Associated Press

A federal judge overturned a black inmate's death sentence because a psychologist told the jury during the punishment phase that the defendant's race could indicate a propensity for violence. The ruling Thursday made Carl Blue, 35, the fourth death row inmate whose sentence was overturned because of the testimony of Walter Quijano, former chief psychologist for the Texas prison system.

9/29/2000...Supreme Court Hears Drug Moms Case...Associated Press

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments Wednesday on whether testing pregnant women for drugs and reporting the results to police violates the Constitution's protection against unreasonable searches.

9/29/2000...Cops Accused of Racial Profiling...Associated Press

San Diego police officers are more likely to stop and search blacks and Hispanics than whites and Asians, according to a study for the police department.

9/27/2000...Acquitted Illinois Men Win Settlement...Associated Press

Two men who were convicted but later acquitted in the 1983 rape and bludgeoning death of a 10-year-old girl will share in a $3.5 million settlement from the county that prosecuted them. A third defendant, whose trial ended in a hung jury, will also receive part of the settlement.

9/27/2000...Supreme Court Adds to Its Calendar...New York Times

The Supreme Court was busy today adding a dozen new cases to their docket for the new term that opens on Monday. One new case assured the new session's status as an important term for the Fourth Amendment law of search and seizure, already the subject of three cases the justices had scheduled for argument during the coming weeks. The case considers whether the use by the police of a thermal imaging device to detect heat patterns inside a home is a search that requires a warrant.

9/26/2000...Court To Hear Prison Clerk Case...Associated Press

The Supreme Court agreed Tuesday to decide whether some prison inmates have a constitutional right to give legal advice to fellow inmates. The justices said they will use a Montana case to decide whether prison officials ever violate inmates' free-speech rights when they censor such communications.

9/26/2000...The Times and Wen Ho Lee...New York Times

The New York Times, which played a leading role in stories about fired Los Alamos physicist Wen Ho Lee, acknowledged in an extraordinary 1,680-word note from the editors Tuesday that its coverage was flawed. In a three-column note titled ''The Times and Wen Ho Lee,'' the newspaper said an internal review ''found some things we wish we had done differently in the course of the coverage to give Dr. Lee the full benefit of the doubt.'' The note appears on page 2, in the space usually dedicated to the index. Here is the actual statement of the New York Times Editors.

9/24/2000...DNA Case May Put N.H. Convictions to Test...Boston Herald

Robert Breest, 62, and a grandfather of five, is the first New Hampshire state inmate to request DNA testing of the evidence used to convict him. New Hampshire's attorney general is fighting that request, saying the state put the right guy behind bars, and that allowing Breest's petition could open the floodgates to frivolous inmate petitions. The historic DNA faceoff is scheduled for this Friday in Concord.

9/24/2000...Tiny Evidence Changing the Face of the Criminal Justice System...Boston Herald

From increasingly smaller fragments of evidence left behind at crime scenes - a speck of dried blood barely visible to the naked eye, or a single strand of hair - scientists are extracting DNA material that is transforming the entire criminal justice system. And igniting a national debate.

9/23/2000...Judge Amends Bail to OK Marijuana Use...Portland Press Herald

A judge has amended bail conditions for a New Vineyard man charged with growing marijuana to allow him to continue to use it for medical reasons. District Judge Robert E. Mullen's decision, likely the first in which a judge has amended bail rules to allow medicinal use of marijuana, stipulates that Leonard Ellis, 62, must comply with Maine's new law.

9/22/2000...Lawyers' Report Blasts the Way Poor Defended...San Antonio Express News

The way Texas provides legal representation to its poor is "a national embarrassment," according to a new report issued by a committee of the State Bar association. After six years of study, the committee found that while Texas leads the nation in executions of criminal defendants — who almost always are indigent — it trails most of the country in providing services to poor people accused of felony crimes..

9/22/2000...Deadly Statistics: A Survey Of Crime and Punishment...New York Times

In its analysis, The New York Times examined homicide rates in two groups of states: the 12 states without the death penalty and the 36 states that passed laws within 10 years of the Supreme Court's 1972 Furman v. Georgia decision, which overturned all existing death penalty statutes. he analysis found that homicide rates have not declined any more in the states that instituted the death penalty than in states that did not.

9/22/2000...States With No Death Penalty Share Lower Homicide Rates...New York Times

The dozen states that have chosen not to enact the death penalty since the Supreme Court ruled in 1976 that it was constitutionally permissible have not had higher homicide rates than states with the death penalty, government statistics and a new survey by The New York Times show.

9/21/2000...Crime Keeps Many Blacks from Voting...Associated Press

On Election Day, nearly 1.4 million voting-age black men -- more than one in eight -- will be ineligible to cast ballots because of state laws that strip felons of the right to vote.

9/21/2000...Electronic Surveillance Puts Police on Probation...Agence France-Presses

Many blacks and Latinos are convinced the mere colour of their skin is enough to get them arrested in many US states. And although top US law enforcement officers bitterly dispute charges of rampant racism among their ranks, that perception, they say, is forcing them to rethink the way they police their roads -- and themselves.

9/21/2000...Proposal on Supreme Court, TV...Associated Press

A bill to require the Supreme Court to televise its public sessions was introduced in the Senate on Thursday.The bill was introduced by Sens. Arlen Specter, R-Pa., and Joseph Biden, D-Del.

9/21/2000...Los Angeles Agrees to Changes for Police...New York Times

Bowing to the inevitable, Los Angeles city officials have agreed to accept a federal court agreement that would require a series of long-sought changes in police management and training to head off a threatened civil rights lawsuit over what the Justice Department has called a systemic pattern of abusive conduct by officers here.

9/21/2000...Statement by Independent Counsel on Conclusions in Whitewater Investigation...New York Times

The text of the statement of independent counsel Robert W. Ray on his office's six-year investigation of the Arkansas business dealings of President and Mrs. Clinton, including the Whitewater land deal.

9/20/2000...Insufficient Evidence to Charge Clintons ...Associated Press

Independent Counsel Robert Ray on Wednesday wrapped up the six-year Whitewater investigation without charging President and Mrs. Clinton with any wrongdoing, handing the White House a bittersweet victory seven weeks before Election Day.

9/20/2000...Border D.A.'s Threaten To Quit ...Associated Press

Almost three months after Congress set aside $12 million for local district attorneys stuck with hand-me-down federal drug cases, frustrated prosecutors are still waiting for the money.

9/20/2000...Report on Prisoner Care Is Used to Pressure State...New York Times

Trying to pressure New Jersey prison officials to disclose whether they are making promised reforms in caring for mentally ill prisoners, a prominent human rights group today released a long-suppressed 1998 report that said the state's treatment of those prisoners was cruel and neglectful.

9/19/2000...Judge Reduces Davidians' Sentence...Associated Press

A federal judge has reduced prison terms for six Branch Davidians, three months after the Supreme Court said he overstepped his authority by exceeding federal sentencing guidelines.

9/18/2000...Committee Proposes Changes to Kansas Forfeiture Law ...Kansas City Star

A legislative committee on Monday recommended changes to the Kansas forfeiture law to address problems in the way the state's law enforcement agencies handle drug money.

9/18/2000...Democrat Puts Hold on Clinton Judicial Nominations ...Associated Press

In an end-of-session twist, Democrats are holding up President Clinton's federal judicial nominations in the Senate hoping to win additional approvals for other judges.

9/18/2000...Asians: Lee Was Victim of Profiling ...Associated Press

Nuclear scientist Wen Ho Lee was the victim of the same type of racial profiling that sent Japanese-Americans to internment camps during World War II, Asian-American civic leaders told a presidential commission Monday.

9/18/2000...Reno: Funds Needed for Ex-Convicts ...Associated Press

The Clinton administration wants Congress to provide $145 million to community-based programs nationwide that help ex-convicts readjust to life on the outside, Attorney General Janet Reno said Monday.

9/18/2000...Prosecutors on the Defensive ...Chicago Sun-Times

The National Association of District Attorneys has hired a full-time public relations specialist for the first time in its history to rebut attacks on the integrity of prosecutors.

9/18/2000...Clinton Celebrates Constitution ...Associated Press

President Clinton marked the 213th anniversary of the signing of the Constitution by attending the groundbreaking Sunday for a museum that will tell the historical document's story. Clinton also watched as 72 immigrants from 23 countries became U.S. citizens.

9/17/2000...D.C. Finds Dangers in Ailing Jail ...Washington Post

The D.C. jail has suffered a severe deterioration in health and environmental conditions, jeopardizing the well-being of inmates and employees and intensifying pressure on the District government to undertake wholesale improvements at the city's main detention facility, according to documents and interviews.

9/17/2000...Marijuana Rally Pushes Legalization ...Associated Press

What was billed as a rally to support marijuana legislation Saturday turned into a drug festival on Boston Common with 40,000 people, many of them minors illegally smoking marijuana.Keith Stroup, executive director of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws, said he disapproved of young people smoking at the event.

9/16/2000...Don't Do Me Like That...Salon Magazine

Add one more recording artist to the growing list of popular musicians who have asked the campaign of Texas Gov. George W. Bush to stop using their music on the stump: Tom Petty. By telling Bush to stop using his hit 1989 single "I Won't Back Down," Petty joins a "USA for Africa"-esque coterie that includes Sting and John Mellencamp telling the Texas governor to knock it off.

9/15/2000...Lieberman Against Music Censorship...Associated Press

Campaigning for the first time with first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton, vice presidential candidate Joseph Lieberman said Friday that censoring music would not help to deter violence.''I don't believe in censorship,''

9/15/2000...Investigation Probes Taped Beating ...Associated Press

Sheriff's agents will criminally investigate the three police officers caught on tape beating and kicking an auto theft suspect after a chase. The Broward County Sheriff's Office findings will be turned over to prosecutors. The Miami-Dade County officers have been reassigned to desk duty while their own department investigates.

9/15/2000...Lawmakers See Hope for Help on Death Cases ...New York Times

Bolstered by findings that even Americans who favor capital punishment worry that innocent people might be put to death, several lawmakers vowed today to renew their push for a law to see that defendants in death- penalty cases have competent lawyers and access to DNA testing.

9/14/2000...Federal Inmate Requests Life Term ...Associated Press

A Hispanic inmate who could become the first person executed by the federal government since 1963 has urged President Clinton to commute his sentence to life in prison because of the ''long-standing racial bias'' involving capital punishment sentencing.

9/14/2000...Glamorous Judge Under Fire ...Associated Press

Last week, Judge Maria Lopez sentenced child molester Charles Horton, a 22-year-old transsexual, to home confinement, despite a prosecutor's request for eight to 10 years in prison. Since then, the spotlight on Lopez has been glaring. Some legislators are demanding her removal from the bench, and columnists and talk show callers have vilified her.

9/14/2000...Gore Closer to Electoral Majority...Associated Press

Al Gore has pulled closer to the 270 electoral votes needed to claim the presidency, generating momentum in battleground states from his rival's mistakes and the public's growing preference for issues over personality, according to an analysis by The Associated Press.

9/14/2000... Statement by Judge in Los Alamos Case With Apology for Abuse of Power ...New York Times

The complete transcript of the statement yesterday by Judge James A. Parker of Federal District Court in Albuquerque to Dr. Wen Ho Lee, who pleaded guilty to mishandling nuclear secrets, as recorded by the court reporter

9/13/2000... Trial Lawyers: Put Death Penalty on Hold ...Charlotte Observer

A group representing 4,000 N.C. lawyers called Tuesday for a moratorium on capital punishment, saying a new poll shows most N.C. residents believe questions about its fairness need to be addressed.

9/13/2000... U.S.-Colombian Drug Fight Underway ...Associated Press

Arriving aboard a U.S.-made combat helicopter, the head of Colombia's national police and the top U.S. drug official in the country watched as heavily armed officers torched a drug lab and dumped coca leaves into a river.

9/13/2000... Nuclear Scientist Wen Ho Lee Is Free ...Associated Press

After nine months in solitary, Wen Ho Lee pleaded guilty Wednesday to just one count of mishandling nuclear secrets and was set free by an apologetic judge who said the government's actions ''embarrassed our entire nation.''

9/13/2000...Reno Troubled by Death Penalty Statistics...New York Times

Saying she was "sorely troubled" by stark racial disparities in the federal death penalty, Attorney General Janet Reno today ordered United States attorneys to help explain why capital punishment is not applied uniformly across ethnic groups.

9/12/2000...U.S. Reiterates Threat of Police Reform Suit...Los Angeles Times

As the Los Angeles City Council prepares today to consider the police reform package its negotiators have worked out with the U.S. Department of Justice, federal officials informed key lawmakers that Atty. Gen. Janet Reno has resolved to obtain a binding agreement to enforce the reforms--and is willing to sue if one is not agreed upon.

9/12/2000...Pervasive Disparities Found in the Federal Death Penalty...New York Times

In the first comprehensive review of the federal death penalty since it was reinstated in 1988, the Justice Department has found significant racial and geographical disparities, say officials who have seen the report. In 75 percent of the cases in which a federal prosecutor sought the death penalty in the last five years,

9/12/2000...Dispute by Lawyers Delays Guilty Plea by Wen Ho Lee...New York Times

A last-minute dispute between the government and defense lawyers over a plea agreement for Wen Ho Lee, the former Los Alamos scientist accused of mishandling nuclear secrets, delayed for at least two days a guilty plea that would allow him to walk out of court a free man.

9/11/2000...Law Professor: L.A. Criminal Justice System Flawed...Reuters

A law professor hired by the union representing rank-and-file Los Angeles police officers said in a report Monday that the city"s criminal justice system faced "grave problems" beyond the so-called Rampart corruption scandal.

9/11/2000...Drug Court to Treat not to Punish...Detroit News

Law enforcement officials and judges are teaming up in Oakland County in a bipartisan effort to establish a treatment-based drug court to replace hard prison time for drug offenders.

9/11/2000...Jailed Scientist OKs Plea Agreement...Associated Press

Los Alamos scientist Wen Ho Lee, who was fired and jailed on charges of mishandling nuclear weapons secrets, has reached a plea bargain in which he will plead guilty to one charge and cooperate with federal investigators, Justice Department sources said.

9/9/2000...Barbados to Put Condom Machines in Jails...Ananova News - U.K.

Prisoners in Barbados will soon have access to condom machines to help stop the spread of HIV. Health Minister Philip Goddard told the Nation newspaper: "If we are advocating safe sex and we recognise the reality of men having sex in prison, then it logically follows that they should have the same protection as the rest of the community."

9/9/2000...House Considers $100, Million More To Colombian Police...Washington Post

Just a week after President Clinton delivered $1.3 billion in aid to Colombian officials for military equipment, counter-drug training and economic assistance, House leaders are considering whether to approve millions of dollars more for anti-drug assistance to the Colombian national police.

9/8/2000...Nader Favors Legalizing Marijuana...Associated Press

Green Party presidential candidate Ralph Nader on Friday advocated the legalization of marijuana as part of an overhaul of the nation's ''self-defeating and antiquated drug laws.''

9/8/2000...Gov. Orders DNA Tests for Inmate...Associated Press

The governor on Friday ordered DNA tests be conducted on evidence that death row inmate Derek Barnabei, who is scheduled to be executed next week, claims will set him free.

9/8/2000...Florida Court Strikes Down Death Penalty Amendment...CNN News. Com/Reuters

Florida's Supreme Court took back its authority to oversee the death penalty Thursday, striking down a popular 1998 constitutional amendment passed by voters who wanted to keep the courts from unduly interfering with executions. By a 4-3 vote, the court said Florida voters were misled in 1998 when they overwhelmingly approved an amendment that enshrined the death penalty in the state Constitution. The amendment prevented any state court from declaring the death penalty unconstitutional.

9/8/2000...Louisiana Settles Suit, Abandoning Private Youth Prisons...New York Times

The State of Louisiana agreed in Federal District Court in Baton Rouge yesterday to sweeping changes in the way it runs its juvenile prisons, including steps to protect inmates from abusive guards and promises to provide medical, dental and mental health care.

9/7/2000...State Police Infiltrated Protest Groups, Documents Show...Philadelphia Inquirer

State police undercover agents posing as demonstrators infiltrated activist groups planning the protests at the Republican National Convention, search-warrant documents made public yesterday showed.

9/7/2000...Justice Department May Probe Police...Associated Press

Citing concerns about the rising number of police shootings, the Justice Department is moving toward a sweeping civil rights investigation of a county police department in Maryland.

9/7/2000...New DNA Tests Are Seen as Key to Virginia Case...New York Times

Lawyers for Earl Washington Jr., a model prisoner with the mental development of a 10-year-old, filed a petition today for a full pardon after 17 years in prison, 6 years after a DNA test raised strong doubts about his conviction in a rape and homicide. Even as the petition was filed, the lawyers were awaiting results of a more definitive DNA test that they said in the petition they were certain would clear Mr. Washington of the crimes.

9/7/2000...FBI Opposes the Profiling of Students...Washington Post

The FBI said yesterday it strongly opposes developing student profiles to predict future violence, favoring instead a series of steps to assess the seriousness of individual threats and determine how to address them.

9/6/2000...Case Against Pot Clinic Staff Is Thrown Out...San Diego Union Tribune

All charges against five people connected to a medicinal marijuana clinic shut down by police earlier this year in Hillcrest were dismissed yesterday by a judge who questioned why the case was even prosecuted.

9/6/2000...Judge Extends Halt to Drug Testing...South Bend Tribune

A temporary restraining order directing the state to stop requiring drug testing for welfare recipients from Berrien County and a handful of other communities has been extended, a federaljudge ruled Tuesday.

9/6/2000...Juvenile Crime Measure Challenged...Associated Press

Six months after voters overwhelmingly approved an overhaul of California's juvenile justice system, the initiative is being challenged in court and its effectiveness is being questioned.

9/6/2000...Court Lifts Stay of Execution...Associated Press

A 7-7 ruling Tuesday from the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals lifts a temporary stay on the planned execution of Philip Workman, who was convicted and sentenced to death for the 1981 slaying of a Memphis police officer. The appeals court had postponed Workman's scheduled April 6 execution indefinitely to hear the defense's claim that Tennessee authorities defrauded the trial court.

9/6/2000...New Yorker Describes Harsh Imprisonment in Peru...New York Times

In her only interview from a Peruvian jail, Lori Berenson describes the harsh conditions of her confinement and tells how her captors have mistreated her fellow prisoners.

9/5/2000...Lawyers Don't Like Money Laundering Law...CBC News

The Canadian Bar Association says a new law would force lawyers to divulge too much confidential information about their clients to federal authorities.

9/5/2000...Inmates Battling West's Fires Help States and Themselves...New York Times

Almost every day since mid-May, Mr. Clark -- convicted most recently of kidnapping -- and the rest of his 20-man crew have been outside the wire, battling blazes across the West....Federal officials say the inmates have been invaluable, providing a much needed, well-trained and well-supervised reinforcement to resources that have worn thin.

9/4/2000...Public Defenders May Fight DNA Decision...USA Today

Public defenders in Vermont are considering asking the Supreme Court to overturn a controversial state court decision that permits police to take DNA samples from potential crime suspects without first obtaining a warrant.

9/1/2000...Waco Whistleblower Faces Indictment...Washington Post

The former U.S. Attorney who sparked a probe into whether the federal government was responsible for the deaths of 74 Branch Davidians near Waco, Tex., has been notified he faces criminal charges after acknowledging he withheld notes from special counsel John C. Danforth's investigators and misled a federal grand jury about the papers.

9/1/2000...Federal Agents Posed as Photographers to Track Skinheads...New York Times

Federal agents posed as members of the news media to take pictures of neo-Nazi skinheads gathered this week to support the Aryan Nations at the trial of a lawsuit against them.

Upcoming Events

The TalkLeft Calendar - Plan to Attend, Watch, Listen and React!

Journey for Justice Texas Journey for Justice, September 22 - September 29, 2000,

Journey for Justice, a caravan of family members of drug war prisoners, medical marijuana patients and citizens who oppose the drug war, will begin a week-long march from Houston to Austin starting September 22. The tour will include vigils, street theater and rallies to highlight various aspects of America's failed war on drugs. For more information, please contact Kevin Aplin of Journey For Justice at (321) 255-9790 or visit www.journeyforjustice.org.

Southern Center for Human Rights 2000 Frederick Douglass Human Rights Award Banquet,Tuesday, October 10, 2000, at 530 p.m., Washington, D.C.

The Center' s 2000 Frederick Douglass Human Rights Award Banquet will be on Tuesday, October 10, 2000, at 530 p.m. at the Marriott Metro Center, Washington, DC. Senator Patrick Leahy of Vermont, sponsor of the Innocence Protection Act of 2000, will give the keynote address. The Center will recognize the work Barry Scheck, Peter Neufeld and James Dwyer. The Innocence Project started and run by Scheck and Peter Neufeld has freed innocent people through the use of DNA testing, and a book by them and James Dwyer, "Actual Innocence," has prompted nation-wide discussion of wrongful convictions. For more information and to reserve seats

Congress Today

Congress Resumes September 5 - 6, 2000.

Election 2000 News

Throughout the day, TalkLeft searches over 1500 news sites on the web for the latest Elections 2000 news and posts them here.

 

Legislative Updates

9/18/00...Current Summary of Criminal Justice Bills Pending in Congress

This legislative status report was prepared by Kevin Driscoll, American Bar Association Senior Legislative Counsel for the ABA Criminal Justice Section on items pending in Congress. Talkleft believes these bills are of interest to the Criminal Defense Community and is re-posting Mr. Driscoll's report here. These issues may see some action before the end of the Congress.

Current Criminal Justice and Civil Liberties Bills in Congress

Tips from the A.C.L.U. for Meeting with Your Elected Officials

Analysis of the Alien Smuggling Bills

Position of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers on S. 1644 and H.R. 238, the alien smuggling bills.

Summary of S. 2463, the National Death Penalty Moratorium Act of 2000

Summary of S. 2463, the National Death Penalty Moratorium Act of 2000, introduced in the Senate on April 26, 2000. The bill's stated purpose is to institute a moratorium on the imposition of the death penalty at the Federal and State level until a National Commission on the Death Penalty studies its use and policies ensuring justice, fairness, and due process are implemented.

Text of S. 2463, the National Death Penalty Moratorium Act of 2000

Action Alert, Stop the Execution of the Innocent

S. 2073, The Innocence Protection Act

The advent of DNA testing raises serious concerns regarding the prevalence of wrongful convictions. The Innocence Protection Act will ensure that wrongfully convicted persons have an opportunity to establish their innocence through DNA testing.

Barry Scheck's Senate Judiciary Committee Testimony on Post-Conviction DNA Testing

Text of S. 2073, the Innocence Protection Act

Federal Grand Jury Reform Report

Read the proposed Grand Juror's Bill of Rights--then contact your elected officials and urge passage!

Op-Ed Columns

TalkLeft's pick of current and thought-provoking Op-Ed Articles

9/29/2000...Imprisonment Should Not Be Revenge...B. Cayenne Bird , LA Times

We're all responsible for ignoring the inhumane conditions that amount to nothing less than torture in California's prisons. Our group of 4,600 doctors, nurses, teachers, college professors and social workers receives hundreds of pleas weekly from the families of inmates asking for help.Somebody needs to sit down and think this crime thing through because the current system is causing more crime than it is preventing. The right thing to do is to release nonviolent prisoners--70% of California's total prison population; institute alternative sentencing for the mentally ill and drug addicts; and send dying prisoners home on compassionate release.

9/27/2000...The Course of Justice...New York Times Editorial

Apart from whatever Supreme Court vacancies may arise, the next president will have the chance to fill numerous vacancies in the lower federal courts. These appointments, especially to the federal courts of appeals, will also have a profound influence on the course of justice. That is another good reason that both candidates should be asked to explain more fully their thinking about judicial nominations whose impact will far outlast the winner's tenure as president.

9/23/2000...Correcting A Mistake by Anthony Lewis, New York Times

Hardly anyone noticed, but the House of Representatives did something rare and admirable the other day. It voted to correct a legislative mistake that has had cruel consequences for thousands of legally admitted aliens: the retroactive deportation feature of the 1996 Immigration Act.

9/22/2000...Free Lori Berenson, New York Times Editorial

Lori Berenson, the American serving a life sentence in Peru for treason, has always been at the mercy of Peru's stormy politics. President Alberto Fujimori has repeatedly used her case to prove he is tough on terrorism and to paint his opponents as squishy.,,,Ms. Berenson's family says that in her new trial, her lawyers have not seen the file of charges and testimony, and were not present when witnesses were questioned. Rather than extending the charade, Mr. Fujimori should let her go.

9/20/2000...Medical Marijuana and Free Speech, New York Times Editorial

The Clinton administration's three-year battle to prevent the use of marijuana as medicine as allowed under California law got a well-deserved rebuke this month. A federal judge wisely ruled that the administration could not punish doctors who recommend the benefits of marijuana to their patients. Such a policy, wrote Judge William Alsup, raises "severe First Amendment doubts."

9/20/2000...Unfinished Work at D.C. Jail, Washington Post Editorial

It was 1971 when advocates first filed a federal lawsuit over inhumane conditions inside the old D.C. Jail. Legal action led to years of court oversight punctuated with grim reports of inmates mistreated or living in filth....A federal judge to agree Monday to return control of part of the operation to the city. But periodic court-ordered inspections of the jail, whose results were reported Sunday by The Post's Serge Kovaleski, continue to turn up deplorable conditions.... As long as inspectors can find the kind of conditions cited in their recent reports, the city hasn't done enough.

9/20/2000...The Return of J. Edgar Hoover...Who's for the Bill of Rights? by Nat Hentoff, Village Voice

There is no way I can vote for the chief executioner of the United States. Since George W. Bush became governor of Texas in 1995, he has executed more people—144 up to now, recently including a mentally retarded prisoner—than any governor in the country. Neither Al Gore, Joseph Lieberman, Bill Clinton, nor Hillary Clinton will criticize Bush for this heap of corpses, because all four are ardent advocates of capital punishment.

9/19/2000...A Ban on Assisted Suicide, New York Times Editorial

The Senate will soon vote on a bill making it a federal crime to prescribe drugs to assist a patient's suicide. Any doctors convicted would serve a mandatory 20 years in prison. The House approved the bill, known as the Pain Relief Promotion Act, last year. The bill is an inappropriate attempt to usurp the power of states to address the profound question of the right to die. President Clinton should veto the bill if the Senate passes it.

9/18/2000...Drugs 'R' Us If We Were Honest by Salim Muwakkil, Chicago Tribune

Deep in the hearts of Americans there lurks an almost religious belief that drug use is not just illegal, but inherently evil and immoral. If rationality guided our drug policies, most of the illegal substances now generating billions of dollars in underground profits would have been decriminalized and drug treatment centers would be wherever they're needed. But our society's attitude about (certain) psychoactive substances is oblivious to rational critique; our demonization of drugs has fanatical and cultlike dimensions.

9/17/2000...Deadly Disparities... New York Times Editorial

Last week's report from the Justice Department confirming stark racial and geographic disparities in the imposition of federal death sentences has underscored the arbitrariness of the nation's death penalty system. The Clinton administration ought to impose a moratorium on the death penalty in federal cases until existing flaws are remedied.

9/16/2000...It Did Happen Here...by Anthony Lewis, New York Times

In excoriating officials for their treatment of Wen Ho Lee, Federal District Judge James A. Parker said one question remained unanswered: "What was the government's motive?" There is an answer to that question, a chilling one. It is: politics.

9/15/2000...Impossibility for Fair Trial for Lori Berenson by Rhoda & Mark Berenson, Common Dreams News Center

Lori Berenson's parents write that "Lori filed a petition with Peruvian officials on 5 Sept. showing that her trial is not proceeding fairly. Unfortunately, it is absolutely impossible for anyone to have a fair trial in terrorism-related cases in Peru, even those heard in the civilian courts, because due process is secondary to expedience within Peruvian law."

9/15/2000...Prisons Are No Cure For Crime...by Vince Shiraldi, San Jose Mercury News

As America's crime rate declined during the past decade, some have been quick to conclude that rising incarceration rates should be credited with the crime drop. But some interesting data have come out over the summer months about the disconnect between incarceration and crime rates that are bad news for prison boosters.

9/15/2000...Wen Ho Lee, Still Not So Very Free...By Gish Jen, New York Times

Is this America? To think of Wen Ho Lee in his nine months of solitary confinement is to think not of Horatio Alger, but of Kafka...Whether or not it can be proved he was a victim of racial profiling, Mr. Lee's case dramatizes what many Americans believe to be true: There is opportunity here, but justice? Equality before the law? No, not for the model minority, it appears.

9/12/2000...Undoing the Damage of the Wen Ho Lee Case...by James Lilley, New York Times

The case of Wen Ho Lee is coming to an end, with the government backing off on virtually all the accusations against him. But the underlying problems of the case are unlikely to disappear once it is resolved, and the government must rethink how it deals with the central conflict between democratic principles and national security....What is needed to regain trust among Asian-Americans are fair, scrupulous and professional investigations; we cannot allow poorly handled cases to alienate a segment of our population.

9/11/2000...Hate Crimes, Thought Police...by William Raspberry, Washington Post

Hate-crime legislation finally turns out to be an attempt at thought control. It says we'll punish you for what you did, yes, but also for what you were thinking when you did it. It says we'll punish you not merely for your racist or anti-gay behavior but also for your bigoted beliefs. How can so many thoughtful people believe that punishing thought is a good idea?

9/9/2000...Membership Has Its Privileges...by Frank Rich, New York Times

You can understand the young George W. Bush wanting to dodge Vietnam, as he did by joining the Texas Air National Guard, a k a the Champagne Unit. But what does it say that the middle-aged Mr. Bush was scared to go to Boston?

9/9/2000...Modern Day Slavery...New York Times Editorial

By a conservative estimate, there are 27 million people working under various forms of slavery in the world today, and the number is growing. In contrast to the slavery America knew, today's slaveholders mainly exploit people of their own race. But as in the American past, they use violence and threats to force people to labor for no pay. Slavery is illegal everywhere, but it thrives because of the corruption of police and government authorities.

9/7/2000...Reasonable Doubt and DNA...by Tim O'Brien, Washington Post

Three weeks ago Larry Youngblood's conviction was vacated. While the small amount of semen that was preserved was insufficient for reliable testing at the time of the appeal, new testing procedures that only recently became available were conducted by the Tucson police. They showed conclusively the police really did have the wrong man...Yet at every turn prosecutors are resisting the use of DNA tests whenever it might mean reopening an old case....To prevent it from happening again, courts must be receptive to any credible claim that new tests might prove the actual innocence of one who has already been convicted. Had Larry Youngblood been charged with first degree murder, he'd probably be dead now.

9/5/2000...Feds' Myths About Medical Marijuana...by Marsha Rosenbaum, San Francisco Chronicle

If any messages have been sent to young people, they are that our system of government does not reflect voters' decisions when those decisions are inconsistent with federal dogma. The reality is that medical marijuana, this small step toward rational drug policy, has not resulted in increased teenage use or in fewer arrests in the general population. What surely has increased among young people is cynicism and mistrust of our government's drug policy.

9/5/2000...America's Crude Approach To Crime And Punishment...by James Carroll, Boston Globe

The solid American commitment to capital punishment which subliminally manifests a quasi-religious faith in human sacrifice, is one indicator that something is askew in our moral reasoning about crime and punishment. Another is the burgeoning prison industry: A few days ago the Justice Department reported that last year, 1,284,894 people were incarcerated in this country.

9/1/2000...Colombia's Drug Problem: Us...by William Raspberry, Washington Post

Andre Pastrana, whether by inadvertence, apolitical candor or devious design, blurted out the truth: The only sure way America can solve its drug problem is by reducing demand. How to do that is, of course, the question. The answers are more likely to include some combination of punishment for casual users and treatment for addicts than the things we've been focusing on in recent years: mandatory sentences and pressure on countries where the stuff is produced. The first has filled our prisons to overflowing with nonviolent offenders, and the second has produced more political instability than measurable benefits.

8/31/2000...From Colombia to Columbia, The War on Drugs is a War on Poor and Black People, by Tom Turnipseed, Common Dreams News Center

From Colombia, South America to Columbia, South Carolina, the "Drug War" is being exposed by human rights organizations as a failed war on drugs, but a disastrously effective war on poor South Americans and black citizens of the United States. The phony drug war is being escalated by a President who "didn't inhale" when they passed the joints around and it's primary victims are Colombian peasants and racially profiled blacks in the U. S.

Current Op-Ed Pieces - Searchable Compilation from Major Newspapers

TalkLeft Commentary

What's Wrong with this Voluntary Confession?...by George Castelle

Examine this frame of a videotape of Austin police officer Robert Merrill's custodial interview of a murder suspect (now facing a trial for first degree murder and a possible death sentence,) then take the short multiple choice test.

Questions I'd Like to Ask George Bush ...by George Castelle, Esq.

How would Presidential candidate George Bush, Jr. fare under an experienced criminal defense lawyer's cross-examination about possible past cocaine usage?

Perspectives on the Bill of Rights - MightyWords.Com

It's the most revolutionary document in American history. Therefore a perfect place to begin a revolution in publishing. Ten unique pieces of digital content (eMatter) on the Bill of Rights today. Called American Perspectives, they are yours to instantly download, print and read. Free from MightyWords.com.

Investigative Reporting

9/27/00...LA Confidential - Ramparts Cover-Up...By Jan Golab, Salon Magazine

A veteran detective says Chief Bernard Parks had evidence of the scandal a year before it was revealed, but kept it from the district attorney -- and the public.

Sept/Oct, 2000...Real Reformers, Real Results...by Keith Meatto, MoJo Wire

MoJo Wire's Seventh Annual Roundup of Student Protest ....including, State University of New York, Albany Student agitation forced SUNY Albany to cancel its dining hall contracts with Sodexho Marriott. Sodexho's parent company is the largest shareholder in Corrections Corporation of America, a leading purveyor of for-profit prisons.

9/18/2000...Declaring War on the War on Drugs...by Anthony York, Salon Magazine

Republican Rep. Tom Campbell takes on Sen. Dianne Feinstein by attacking U.S. drug policy. Sure, it's California -- but does he have a chance?

9/14/2000...Doubt on Death Row...By Ashley Fantz, Salon Magazine

Despite a partisan tie vote, Tennesee convict Philip Workman faces execution, while the country faces new facts about the death penalty.

9/11/2000...Attorney's Inexperience No Barrier...Dallas Morning News

Attorney Kerry Lee had no permanent license to practice law and no background in capital murder defense. But he was appointed by a trial judge to handle the appeal of death row inmate Henry Lee Dunn Jr. Mr. Lee had been practicing law for less than two years. And the state's highest criminal appeals court let him stay on the case even after he signaled his inexperience by asking the court to delay the appeal so he could take an introductory course in death-penalty defense.

9/11/2000...Questions of Competence Arise in Death Row Appeal...Dallas Morning News

Joe Lee Guy was sentenced to die for being an accomplice in a store owner's slaying; the triggerman and a second accomplice were sentenced to life . The man appointed to fight for Mr. Guy's life was Richard Lee Wardroup, a Lubbock lawyer with a history of professional misconduct and alcoholism. Though Mr. Wardroup's problems stemmed from other cases, his conduct in Mr. Guy's trial is now under attack by appellate lawyers.

9/10/2000...Judge Says Inmate Wrongly Convicted...Dallas Morning News

A disabled oilfield roughneck was unknowingly drugged, denied access to evidence and sentenced to die even though the state's case against him lacked physical evidence, eyewitnesses or a motive linking him to the crime.

9/10/2000...Errors, Inequities Often Cloud Capital Cases in the Carolinas by Ames Alexander, Liz Chandler, Charlotte Observer

Capital punishment in the Carolinas is so tainted with mistakes, inequities and incompetence that the system risks executing innocent people, while sparing some of the states' most vicious killers, an Observer investigation has found.

9/10/2000...The Maximum Security Adolescent by Margaret Talbot, New York Times Magazine

The juvenile justice system, founded on the idea that childhood is a distinct stage of life, is being dismantled, with more and more teenagers imprisoned alongside adults. The tough-on-crime crowd has won, but what kind of society has been left behind?

Sound Bytes

9/13/2000...Court Apology to Nuclear Scientist Dr. Wen Ho Lee, ...New York Times

"Dr. Lee, I tell you with great sadness that I feel I was led astray last December by the executive branch of our government through its Department of Justice, by its Federal Bureau of Investigation and by its United States attorney for the district of New Mexico, who held the office at that time."

Complete Transcript of Judge's Statement

Political Cartoons

Doonesbury and New York Times Cartoons

Daily Selection From Around the Country

Hot Reads

Actual Innocence: Five Days to Execution and Other Dispatches from the Wrongly Convicted
by Barry Scheck, Peter Neufeld, Jim Dwyer

Reads like a novel but much scarier because it's all true. A page-turner! Read a Chapter Excerpt

Order Your Copy Today!


In Association with Amazon.com   Start your Amazon purchase here and help support this site!

Talk Line 2000 Archives

Past issues for those just discovering TalkLeft

August, 2000
July, 2000
June, 2000
May, 2000
April, 2000
March, 2000
February, 2000
January, 2000

About TalkLeft  

All Content Copyright © 2000, Crimelynx® Inc.  All rights reserved.

FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of criminal justice, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.