Howard Bashman of How Appealing , in the last paragraph of his post, sends us to Memeufacture, a Weblog and Automated Trend Reporting site. Memeufacture scans hundreds of websites of different "genres" with some sort of formula using a python program, and comes up with the most popular sites in various categories, followed by the most influential sites in the same categories.*

How Appealing is the second most influential blog in the "law" category. We thought Howard was just being modest when he said there must be an error in balloting. So we went to Memeufacture to take a look. TalkLeft isn't in the law category at all, it's in the Politics-Left category, and they list TalkLeft as the second most influential weblog in the "Politics-Left" Category. Here are their top ten (as of this moment):

1 : Eschaton
2 : TalkLeft: The Politics of Crime
3 : BuzzFlash - Daily Headlines and Breaking News
4 : Taegan Goddard's Political Wire
5 : TAPPED
6 : Cursor.org -
7 : Daily Kos: Political analysis and other daily rants on the state of the nation
8 : Matthew Yglesias
9 : NathanNewman.org - News and Views
10 : Eric Alterman: Altercation

Now, we know we get linked to a bunch, but still, number two in that category, when compared to the others? In our dreams, maybe.

For Politics - Right, Instapundit is the most influential, and Oliver Willis is number 6. Wonder what Oliver will have to say about being in this category at all.

The most popular left political sites (as opposed to most influential) are:

1 : NathanNewman.org - News and Views: Pickering and Anti-Klan Testimony
2 : Eschaton
3 : Spinsanity - Taxing the public's trust: The Bush administration is stretching the truth again to sell its latest tax cut
4 : Long story; short pier.: Boom and Bust.
5 : Altercation: Slacker Friday
6. the next five are mainstream media newspapers

*This is Memeufacture's description of what they do: "The automatic content is generated using a simple Python program (about 200 lines.) Memeufacture scans hundreds of websites of several different genres. It determines which links are most popular and which websites posted those links first."

We are obviously missing something here. Can anyone explain Memeufacture and what they are measuring?

Update: We also expressed our puzzlement via e-mail to Memeufacture's chief, John Weher. He has replied:

The ranking mechanism is automated and objective.

Essentially it works by recording who links to what first. If two sites link to the same site at once, it is counted as a tie and disqualified. The rankings change quite frequently, but it is interesting to see the sites that consistently stay near the top, such as instapundit, metafilter and talkleft.

Your being listed in the top means that you tend to point out issues that others find important (and link to) later on. Congratulations for running a great site.