Ten years. That's tbe sentence imposed on the first of the "Buffalo Six" defendants today. For what?

Mukhtar al-Bakri went to Afganistan and attended a training camp. He heard Osama bin Laden speak there. Then he got married. The day after his wedding, while in Bahrain, he got arrested. Then charged with providing material support to a terrorist organization.

The Government acknowledged it had no evidence that al-Bakri or his confederates planned a terrorist act. What it had was a theory dependent upon guilt by association and perceived thought.

"It's the first time in American history where people are going to prison for going to a training camp," said David D. Cole, a Georgetown University law professor ..... "It's wrong. . . . It's unconstitutional." Cole said he believes that the section of law used to convict the six men is unconstitutional and will be struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court within the next couple of years.

Elaine Cassel, a Virginia lawyer and civil rights advocate, calls the Lackawanna case "one of the worst examples of the vengeful Bush and Ashcroft battle against terrorism." "It's like the movie "Minority Report,' " Cassel said. "The idea is, "Let's go out and arrest people before they actually commit a crime, or even think of a crime.' "

A hollow and ominous victory for Ashcroft.

[comments now closed]