home

The Justice Dept.'s Bogus Terrorist Statistics

According to the LA Times, the Justice Department is using a flawed terrorist yardstick to inflate the number of terrorist arrests.

DOJ cites 280 cases as proof that it is winning the terror war.

The growing list has been regularly highlighted by Ashcroft and other Justice Department officials in speeches and congressional testimony, and even by President Bush. In an address to federal law enforcement officials on the eve of the anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks, Bush referred to the "more than 260 suspected terrorists" that the government has hauled to court.

In October, testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee, Christopher Wray, the Justice Department's criminal division chief, cited the growing number of charges resulting from terrorism probes — which then stood at 284 defendants — as evidence that the department has "enjoyed key successes" in the anti-terrorism war. Last month, in a speech before a Justice Department liaison group for federal attorneys, Ashcroft cited terrorism-related criminal charges against 286 people, declaring "we have been successful."

Partly using documents it obtained under the Freedom of Information Act, the LA Times conducted its own review of the cases.

The Times' request for government records on the cases turned up a highly redacted accounting covering only about half the number that Ashcroft trumpets. Some of those cases were on a list that the department produced in the months after the Sept. 11 attacks in response to a lawsuit by civil liberties groups.....the list obtained by The Times also includes two New Jersey men, operators of small grocery stores, who were convicted of accepting hundreds of boxes of stolen breakfast cereal, in a crime that occurred 16 months before the terrorist hijackings.

Also included is a Somali who was convicted in federal district court in Boston of operating an unlicensed money-transfer business, in which the judge rebuked prosecutors for trying to have him sentenced as a terrorist.

The Times analysis is in line with a study released a few weeks ago by Syracuse University--that we wrote about here--which found that "the median sentence for defendants in international terrorism cases won by the department is two weeks." The Syracuse study can be found here.

< Dean Offered Clark No. 2 Spot | Will the U.S. Get Stuck With the Bill for Saddam's Trial? >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort: