Calculating Martha Stewart's Sentence
Findlaw columnist Mark Allenbaugh calculates Martha's federal sentencing guidelines at 30 to 37 months, and predicts she will serve 32 months. We disagree. Our calculations are here. Note: If you're not a lawyer, your eyes may glaze over at this.
We predict her guidelines will come out at either 10 to 16 months or 18 to 24 months--depending on whether the Judge enhances her guidelines based on a finding that her obstruction significantly interfered with the administration of justice.
Substantial interference with the administration of justice" includes a premature or improper termination of a felony investigation; an indictment, verdict, or any judicial determination based upon perjury, false testimony, or other false evidence; or the unnecessary expenditure of substantial governmental or court resources.
Also, the obstruction enhancement generally doesn't apply to convictions for obstruction. While it might apply to the false statements charge, the grouping rules provide for use of the obstruction guideline so we don't think that will come into play.
2. Nonapplicability of Chapter Three, Part C.—For offenses covered under this section, Chapter Three, Part C (Obstruction) does not apply, unless the defendant obstructed the investigation, prosecution, or sentencing of the obstruction of justice count.
The base guideline for obstruction is now 14, but we believe it was 12 at the time of the crime. The guideline to be used is that in effect at the time of sentencing, unless it was less at the time of the crime. [fn1]
We'd like to see appellate lawyer Peter Goldberger (and any other federal sentencing guideline pros) weigh in on this.
< Terry Nichols' Juror Reports Others Lying to Get on Jury | Life on the Outside > |