home

Many Republicans Bucking Bush on Gay Marriage Amendment

by TChris

President Bush's call for a constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage appears to be a non-starter as some Republicans in Congress resist his invitation to divide the country further over an issue that is better left to the states.

In the Senate, at least one-third of the 51 Republicans have withheld support from the proposed amendment. Some assert that Congress should wait until federal courts or state legislatures grapple with gay marriages. Others believe the measure discriminates against gays and lesbians. Many say amending the Constitution should be a last resort.

Only one Senate Democrat supports the amendment (Zell Miller, a Democrat in name only who supports the reelection of President Bush), while the sole Independent in the Senate opposes it. All Senate Republicans and sixteen Democrats would need to vote in favor of the amendment, as would two-thirds of the House, before the amendment could move forward.

Perhaps to the President's surprise, that level of support just isn't in the cards.

House Majority Leader Tom Delay thinks it would be difficult to find the needed 290 votes in the House. Senator Orrin Hatch, often a conservative leader on social issues, is unwilling to engage in gay bashing to solidify Republican support by social conservatives. Says Hatch:

"Everybody around here knows I don't believe in discrimination. I don't want to hurt gays. Some of the most talented people in our society today are gays."

Although Hatch supports a version of the amendment that would allow state recognition of civil unions, some social conservatives are angry that Hatch is searching for a middle ground.

"The problem in the Senate, and it's a serious problem, can be summed up in two words: 'Orrin Hatch,'" said Paul Weyrich, president of the Free Congress Foundation and a longtime conservative activist. "He is actively discouraging Republicans from supporting the Federal Marriage Amendment, telling them, 'it's not going to pass, so why get yourself out on a limb?'"

Even the Republican who drafted the federal Defense of Marriage Act, former Representative Bob Barr of Georgia, opposes amending the Constitution. He will be the first witness at a hearing Tuesday before the House Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution.

Why this lack of support on an issue that President Bush seized in his attempt to win reelection?

Patrick Guerriero, executive director of the Log Cabin Republicans, a gay-rights group, said some Republicans are pushing back from the issue, because it makes them uncomfortable. "This is a civil rights issue that is moving faster than anyone imagined, and most elected officials are afraid to be on the wrong side of history," he said.

As they should be. Don't expect to hear the President making gay marriage the front-and-center issue in his reelection speeches, given the tepid support his party is giving him on the issue.

< High Electric Bill Leads to Search | Why Do We Pay Chalabi? >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft