home

Upcoming Murder Trial to Test the System

Bump and Update: 13 year old Jake Eakin finally gets an experienced lawyer to defend him against adult murder charges.

****************
original post

Read this one...Not even Scott Turow or John Grisham could make this up. A juvenile murder trial, a 'sleeping judge, a 'felon prosecutor' and an inexperienced defense attorney. By award-winning journalist Ken Armstrong (formerly of Mills/Armstrong Chicago Tribune fame) and Jonathan Martin in today's Seattle Times. 13 year old Craig Sorger is murdered and two of his 12 year old playmates are charged:

The two suspects, Evan Savoie and Jake Eakin, are scheduled to stand trial Sept. 14 in Grant County Superior Court. They will be the youngest murder defendants tried as adults in the state's modern history.....police questioned the two boys [who were] last seen with Craig — each 12 years old, and neither in trouble with the law before. Police would question them again and again in days to come, collecting shifting statements that were not confessions, but that would lead prosecutors to charge them with first-degree murder.

...To research this story, The Seattle Times obtained police reports, 911 transcripts, hearing transcripts, medical and psychological reports, court records, judicial disciplinary records, school records, crime-lab and autopsy reports and state court data. Reporters interviewed the defendants and their parents, Craig Sorger's parents, attorneys in the case and others.

....The decision to try the boys as adults — a rare step for children that young — poses questions that go beyond evidence: Can children understand their rights? Aid in their defense? Know right from wrong? With its legal complexities and factual holes, this case would test the best criminal-justice system. But Grant County's is one of the state's worst.

The trial judge has been censured for incompetence, the prosecutor has been convicted of a drug felony, and the county's public-defense system is the subject of a class-action lawsuit.

Also check out Dr. Helen Smith's movie Six . It's a remarkable film that raises important issues society should be addressing with respect to violent juvenile crime.

< Mark Geragos Goes After Amber Frey | First Intelligence Officers to be Charged in Abu Ghraib Abuse Scandal >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort: