home

DNA Tests Sought for Texecution Under Bush's Watch

The Texas legislature is holding hearings today on the establishment of an Innocence Commission. Barry Scheck, Co-director of the Innocence Project, will testify. He will ask Governor Rick Perry for DNA testing in the case of Claude Jones, who was executed five years ago while George Bush was Governor, because of information that has surfaced indicating that Bush knew about a request for DNA testing of a hair sample used to convict Jones and didn't acknowledge it.

Barry Scheck, co-founder of Benjamin Cardozo School of Law's Innocence Project, is scheduled to make the request before the Texas Senate's Criminal Justice Committee, which is holding a hearing on whether to establish a state innocence commission.

.... Scheck is requesting DNA testing on a single strand of hair in the case of Claude Jones, who was executed in December 2000 for armed robbery and murder. According to prosecutors, Jones shot and killed Allen Hilzendager while robbing his liquor store in Point Blank, Texas, in November 1989.

....Jones' convictions were based largely on what Scheck says is dubious evidence. It included testimony from an accomplice who linked Jones to the slaying, and the report of a state forensic scientist who examined a 1-inch length of hair found at the scene and said that it was similar to Jones' hair.

Accomplice testimony and microscopic hair comparison testimony are notoriously unreliable. Now that DNA testing of hair is possible, Scheck says it should be done. The Tribune has uncovered information that a request for it was made right before Jones' execution, and Bush did not acknowledge it in refusing to grant a stay of execution:

Scheck said in an interview Monday that while he is not prepared to argue that Jones is in fact innocent, there is a question of whether then-Gov. Bush knew of Jones' request for the DNA testing when refusing to grant a last-minute plea for a stay of execution.

According to records gathered by Scheck, a request for a 30-day stay to allow DNA testing of the hair was filed with the governor's office on the day Jones was scheduled to be executed by lethal injection.

According to notes found in Jones' file at the Texas Department of Public Safety, the agency that handled the hair comparison at Jones' trial, a member of Bush's staff called that day to ask about the hair comparison in the case. The governor's aide was urged, according to the notes, to contact the FBI about "the likelihood of obtaining . . . DNA results from a 1" hair fragment."

But when the final summary of the case was sent to Bush for his decision on whether to stop the execution, there was no mention of the request for DNA testing of the hair, according to a copy of the summary obtained by the Tribune. "The only decision to be made is whether to grant a 30-day reprieve," the summary, written by an assistant general counsel for Bush, said. "At this time, I do not recommend that a reprieve be granted . . . " That attorney declined to comment Monday.

< How Will the Right Spend the Schiavo Money? | This Day in History >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Culture of WHAT?

    A snow ball in the vatican will have a better chance. The idea that texas will take a risk at embarrassing Bushbag is pure fantasy. thats my opinion and i'm sticking to it!

    Thank God I Am not human I Have no DNA.

    Point Blank, Texas? A shooting? At point blank?

    Re: DNA Tests Sought for Texecution Under Bush's W (none / 0) (#5)
    by Che's Lounge on Tue Apr 19, 2005 at 02:18:47 PM EST
    Could it be that the first man discovered to be wrongfully executed in this country was sent there by the POTUS?

    Re: DNA Tests Sought for Texecution Under Bush's W (none / 0) (#6)
    by wishful on Tue Apr 19, 2005 at 02:41:12 PM EST
    Ed, you are quite generous if you think that the worst that can happen to the POTUS is embarrassed. If the allegations of Bushie's foreknowledge of potential proof of innocence are true, and if the DNA does prove the innocence of the man Bush killed, that is more than embarrassing. Oh, wait. I keep forgetting that we live in the new fundamentalist, born-again, culture-of-life Bushworld. Bush can kill whoever he damn well pleases, when ever and how ever he pleases. It is so hard for me to keep up with the rules of our new democracy.

    Re: DNA Tests Sought for Texecution Under Bush's W (none / 0) (#7)
    by jondee on Tue Apr 19, 2005 at 03:16:15 PM EST
    If he'll go along with executing ten thousand innocents in Iraq to further the cause, you can bet your a** he'd expedite the demise of another wretched "expendable" in Texas.

    Re: DNA Tests Sought for Texecution Under Bush's W (none / 0) (#8)
    by Lindsay on Tue Apr 19, 2005 at 05:25:19 PM EST
    I remember when he was running for President in 2000 and he said with absolute certainty that he had never executed an innocent man. Yeah, right!

    Re: DNA Tests Sought for Texecution Under Bush's W (none / 0) (#9)
    by Johnny on Tue Apr 19, 2005 at 05:45:50 PM EST
    If he doesn't look at the evidence, he can say with certainty that he has never killed an innocent man. If, and only if, this hair is tested will we know. And if it turns out an innocent man was killed, and if BushCo does not suppress the knowledge that Bush "refused/denied/pretended it didn't exist" DNA testing, then we can just chalk it up to youthful indiscretion.

    Don't forget that Alberto was giving him legal advice when he was governing Tx, my home state. Wonder what part Alberto has in the DNA testing?