home

Why So Many Died at New Orleans Hospitals and Nursing Homes

by TChris

No level of government did an adequate job of helping hospitals and nursing homes that failed to carry out their responsibility to evacuate patients from New Orleans. The consequences of those failures were often fatal.

Of the dead collected so far in the New Orleans area, more than a quarter of them, or at least 154, were patients, mostly elderly, who died in hospitals or nursing homes, according to interviews with officials from 8 area hospitals and 26 nursing homes. By the scores, people without choice of whether to leave or stay perished in New Orleans, trapped in health care facilities and in many cases abandoned by their would-be government rescuers.

At least 91 patients died in hospitals and 63 in nursing homes not fully evacuated until five days after the storm, according to the interviews, although those numbers are believed to be incomplete. In the end, withering heat, not floodwaters, proved the deadliest killer, with temperatures soaring to 110 degrees in stifling buildings without enough generator power for air-conditioning.

In some cases, FEMA hindered evacuation efforts.

Yet when private companies dispatched helicopters, trucks and buses to evacuate hospitals and nursing homes, officials from the Federal Emergency Management Agency commandeered some of them for other uses, hospital and nursing home officials said.

By the time help arrived, it came too late for some.

As military helicopters equipped with seats, not stretchers, ferried healthy adults to safety, patients awaiting evacuation died, hospital staff members said.

The linked article contains a wealth of detail about communications breakdowns, the state legislature's refusal to appropriate adequate money for nonprofit hospitals, and the failure of anyone to notice that multiple nursing homes had contracted with the same bus companies to evacuate patients, assuring that there wouldn't be enough busses to meet the demand. It makes for grim reading, and should be included in disaster management textbooks to assure these mistakes aren't made again.

< Guantanamo: Starving for Justice | Election Reform Proposed >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Ha... that's an easy one...and I'm very surprised nobody on here has said it yet... It's obviously all GW's fault! After all... He is responsible for everything else! For example... #1 - New Orleans being built below sea level. #2 - The levee system not being able to handle anything above a cat 3 storm.(nevemind it's been that way for over 100 years!) #3 - Any and all hurricanes that hit the US #4 - The bad judgments and mistakes of both the mayor of N.O. and the Gov of the state.. All GW's fault! Ok...you can close this blog now!

    Hey TChris.... Instead of blaming their "would be Government rescuers".. How about blaming the "actual" guilty parties... that would be the people in charge of these people's welfare...(IE - the people than ran the homes they were in!) Is there anything you won't blame our Government for?

    BB...I agree. Let's give Bush his props. He has kept us safe from Iraq's weapons of mass destruction.

    Ernesto... Good comeback.... how about staying on the subject....? Or should I bring up Billy's BJ's?

    how about staying on the subject....?
    Actually, I was staying on subject...since Dubya's disastrous occupation of Iraq ended up meaning more people would drown in our own backyard.

    Ernesto... From the article you cite...."Asked Tuesday about critics who said the commitment of large numbers of troops to the Iraq conflict hindered the military's response to Hurricane Katrina, Rumsfeld said, "Anyone who's saying that doesn't understand the situation." Does that mean you Ernesto? "Iraq and other overseas commitments do not inhibit our ability to sustain this effort here at home," But go ahead & keep grasping at those straws dude!

    You are gonna use a Rumsfeldism to refute what the generals in the field are saying. Isn't that where we went wrong in Iraq? BB...must stand for "Bush Believer". Or is it "Bullsh1t Buyer"? Or some combination thereof? Well what does one expect of someone that repeats urban legend emails. Hey BB, I am related to the Sultan of Nigeria whose fortune will be yours if you send me only 5,000 dollars. I will email you with more details, OK?