home

Wrongful Convictions in France

by TChris

The United States, of course, isn’t the only country with a criminal justice system that leads to wrongful convictions. When the system breaks down in France, at least the government has the good grace to apologize.

A French appeals court today overturned the conviction of six people accused of participating in a pedophilia ring in northern France five years ago, unraveling one of the most mismanaged cases in French judicial history and leaving the nation asking how the court system could have gone so awry.

"I apologize to the acquitted and their families," the French justice minister, Pascal Clément, said at a press conference after the appeal verdict was announced in Paris. He ordered investigations of the police, judiciary and social services involved in the case and asked for a report by February.

The apology comes too late for a seventh innocent man, who committed suicide in prison. The chief prosecutor asked the appellate court to acquit the six remaining defendants and demanded an investigation to determine responsibility for the wrongful convictions.

False accusations of child molestation are particularly troubling because members of the community tend to rally around the children, no matter how preposterous their claims may be. That’s what happened in the infamous McMartin preschool case, among others in this country, and it’s now happening in Europe.

The decision reinforces concerns about cases that rely on the testimony of children, particularly amid what some sociologists and child-abuse experts call the "hysteria" that has crept across Europe following the arrest of a Belgian, Marc Dutroux, for kidnapping, raping and killing children nearly a decade ago.

< China, Iran, Vietnam....and the U.S. | Nguyen Tuong Van Prepares for Death at Dawn >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: Wrongful Convictions in France (none / 0) (#1)
    by sarcastic unnamed one on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 01:06:36 PM EST
    "The United States, of course, isn’t the only country with a criminal justice system that leads to wrongful convictions. When the system breaks down in France, at least the government has the good grace to apologize."...TChris I gotta give my props to TChris on this one. I so wanted to prove this statement wrong, but I can't. I can't find any example of the US gvt appologizing for a wrongful conviction.

    Re: Wrongful Convictions in France (none / 0) (#2)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Dec 17, 2005 at 01:06:36 PM EST
    Closest thing I can remember to a US government apology came from the judge in the Wen Ho Lee case:
    "Although, as I indicated, I have no authority to speak on behalf of the Executive Branch, the President, the Vice-president, the Attorney General, or the Secretary of the Department of Energy, as a member of the Third Branch of the United States Government, the Judiciary, the United States Courts, I sincerely apologize to you, Dr. Lee, for the unfair manner you were held in custody by the Executive Branch."
    Not quite the same, especially since the Executive Branch then proceeded to extract a guilty plea on one felony count of improperly downloading restricted information.