home

A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform

by TChris

Paul Butler explains why he worked as a federal prosecutor.

"I was hired to be a black prosecutor, and I was a damned good one," the George Washington University professor said Thursday in the Law School's Martin Luther King Jr. Lecture.

He also explains why he quit.

"I didn't go to law school to put black people in prison," Butler said.

What changed? Butler started listening to hip-hop. More prosecutors -- and anyone else who wants to understand how the criminal justice system is frequently perceived -- should give it a try.

"When I listened to hip-hop music, I found a better way to think about the criminal justice system than in the prosecutor's office," Butler said.

There's a constant in hip-hop culture, a criticism of the criminal justice system. The culture says that the system is dysfunctional.

...

Hip-hop as a whole is criticized for its support of criminals, but really the culture is just about "respecting young black men," Butler said. He added that one in three young black men have been arrested.

Hip-hop not only critiques the criminal justice system, but also suggests ways in which it can be improved. According to Butler, the hip-hop view of the system is that prison is simply a bad thing that happens to some people.

Butler believes that reordering our law enforcement priorities would improve the perception that the criminal justice system targets minorities.

Butler believes that one big difference between the criminal justice system that is currently in place and the hip-hop system would be that the usage and selling of drugs would not be as highly prosecuted.

"This is not because they are victimless crimes," Butler said. "This is because they don't trust the government to enforce it fairly."

According to statistics that Butler cited from the Department of Justice, only 12 percent of drug users are black, but 75 percent of the people who are prosecuted on drug-related charges are black.

Butler makes a number of good points, including this: if you want to improve the system, you aren't going to do it as a federal prosecutor. At least, not in a Justice Department controlled by the Bush administration.

< Reforming Sex Offender Registration | PA Considers Comm'n to Study Wrongful Convictions >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform (none / 0) (#1)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Mon Feb 20, 2006 at 10:13:05 AM EST
    Butler's makes a number of good points, including this: if you want to improve the system, you aren't going to do it as a federal prosecutor.
    I doubt there's more than 5-10 prosecutors in the whole country who think the system needs improving in the first place (except to put MORE people in for MORE time). Too many of them have the same mindset as Nancy Grace and that despicable Bruce Castor in PA, where every person is a criminal until that person proves otherwise. That kind of thinking and behavior is in immediate need of overhaul. That said, I'm sure the trolls will have some lovely comments to this post...

    Re: A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform (none / 0) (#2)
    by swingvote on Mon Feb 20, 2006 at 10:20:24 AM EST
    I can't argue with the idea that some of our priorities are screwed up when it comes to law enforcement (they are), but I have to wonder about the claim that, because hip-hop sees the system as dysfunctional, we should listen to hip-hop artists who have ideas for reforming the system. After all, the people who create hate-rock probably also have some ideas about how the system is broken and how it should be fixed, but I don't see TChris fronting for them. Then again, a large part of society sees hip-hop itself as dysfunctional, and could offer lots of advice on how to fix it. Do you think Kanye West will listen?

    Re: A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform (none / 0) (#3)
    by jimcee on Mon Feb 20, 2006 at 07:20:40 PM EST
    So the Hip-hop folks have a problem with the law? Who'd a thought. Mr Rhymes, please call Commisioner Kelly he has some questions about a murder you possibly witnessed. I watched a show on some Skinheads last night on A&E and they seemed to think that the judicial system was rigged against them and most of them had been in prison at one time or another. While the show was being made they were shaken-down by the ATF for no apparent reason. Perhaps the Hip-Hop fellas could get together with the skinheads and change the judicial system in a way that helps the both of them? I didn't think so.

    Re: A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform (none / 0) (#4)
    by Johnny on Mon Feb 20, 2006 at 10:04:25 PM EST
    Jimcee, you forgot the country-western folks.

    Re: A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform (none / 0) (#5)
    by jimcee on Mon Feb 20, 2006 at 10:57:32 PM EST
    Johnny, I really don't know much about the Country folks but if you're talking opera, classical or even '70's blues/art/rock or even old real country or bluegrass I might have an opinion but Modern Country Pop? I have no idea, you tell me.

    Re: A Hip-Hop View of Criminal Justice Reform (none / 0) (#6)
    by Johnny on Tue Feb 21, 2006 at 06:19:10 AM EST
    I don't know if Jimcee was trying to wow me with the amount of different music he listens to or was trying to tell me that he doesn't consider modern country "real". I am guessing both. My point was, country music (which by all accounts is listened to by a lot of people) is concerned with social injustice quite a bit. And in many cases, the inadequacy of the court system. Of course, when the inadequacy is addressed in a very popular song about lynch-mob justice, I can see why the wrong wingers conveniently forget to include country music in.