home

A Literary Conflict of Interest

by TChris

A prosecutor got herself tossed from a case because its facts were too similar to those of a crime novel she'd authored and was promoting at the time of the prosecution. The defense raised a "novel" question in seeking her disqualification.

In January, Joyce Dudley, a deputy district attorney in Santa Barbara, published a crime novel called "Intoxicating Agent." Its heroine, Jordon Danner, has the same initials and the same job as Ms. Dudley, and the novel concerns a rape case with echoes of a real one. In both, the victim said she had been sexually assaulted after being given an intoxicating drug. ...

"She has a disabling conflict of interest," Justice Kenneth R. Yegan of the California Court of Appeal wrote of Ms. Dudley for a unanimous three-judge panel. Ms. Dudley must be disqualified, Justice Yegan continued, because the defendant, Massey Haraguchi, "is being prosecuted for raping an intoxicated person while the prosecutor is promoting her novel involving the identical charge."

Justice Yegan wrote that Ms. Dudley's desire for money and fame might tempt her to throw the book at the defendant, as it were.

< North Korea's Nuclear Option | Zakaria on Iraq: Time to Leave >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: A Literary Conflict of Interest (none / 0) (#1)
    by cpinva on Mon Oct 09, 2006 at 11:42:43 AM EST
    ya know (and yes, i am a pig! :)) the lady is just not all that great looking, or maybe she needs to drop the affected cowboy hat for publicity shots. an interesting case. while i think the court overreached, ms. dudley probably should have recused herself from the case, for appearance sake, if nothing else. why give a defendant another reason to appeal, if found guilty?