home

I Wish Thanksgiving Was For All of Us

I'm not in a particularly upbeat mood this Thanksgiving. I know we just won an election and hopefully have started on a path to end the War in Iraq and take back our country from the right-wing extremists who have ruled since 1994. I'm thankful that the days of appointing right-wing ideologues to our federal courts and the Supreme Court may be behind us.

But I live in a peculiar world, one that is filled with days spent visiting mostly non-violent prisoners in jails, and it saddens me that for them and their children and parents, I see little hope.

For two hours on Sunday night, I sat on a cold bench at the jail in Omaha, waiting to get in to see a client (the mechanical doors had malfunctioned, and there was nothing anyone could do until a repairman fixed them.) The bench was in a waiting room between the door to the outside world and the partitioned glass window where a lone sheriff's deputy sat, taking money from a stream of inmate family members, who were bringing it to be placed on the inmate's accounts so they could buy food and hygiene items from the commissary.

In order for the inmate to be able to purchase anything from the commissary and receive it by Thursday for Thanksgiving, the money had to be in by Sunday night. The Sheriff's deputy would come out for five minute stretches and then disappear behind closed doors for a half hour or so. During the time she was gone, the room would fill with parents, grandparents and children, all coming to put $20 or $40 on their loved one's "book" so that their Thanksgiving would be a little less dreary. The line got really long at times and I got to hear all their stories.

There was the 78 year old grandmother, who had no idea why her grandson hadn't spent more time reading the bible, but wouldn't abandon him. The teenage daughters who reminded me of the Bush twins, stunning in their petulance at having to wait. "Don't these people work for us? Aren't we paying their salaries?"

The working mother who fretted she would be late to work but couldn't leave before making sure her son wouldn't have an empty Thanksgiving. A young man who had stopped by to pick up his "store" -- the commissary items he had purchased during his 90 day stay -- but weren't delivered to him when he was released the day before. His stories about the food served at the jail left me no doubt why his "store," when it was finally turned over, was filled with Snickers bars and Fritos.

It was just a parade of pitifuls, one after the other. The saddest part was that, except for having to wait for the appearance of the Sheriff's deputy, they all accepted these conditions. Once they got to tender their money, they all wished the Sheriff's Deputy a happy holiday, and she replied in kind.

Back in Denver today, I spent the morning with a young female inmate who hasn't seen her kids in a few months. She's not yet been convicted, but is missing Thanksgiving because she was denied bond since she's charged with a federal drug offense and the Government requested she be held until trial without bond. As I left, I mentioned I wouldn't be back until next week, due to the Thanksgiving holiday and the fact that my mother was in the hospital. She told me not to worry, she'd be fine. She told me to give her blessings to my mother.

I spent the afternoon with a formerly well-to-do businessman, his wife and daughter as they tried to accept that he would be going to prison for a few years for an economic crime he never thought was against the law. The tears, the sadness, the coming to grips with reality -- is it really necesary?

The incarcerated are human beings too. Everyone is more than the sum of their misdeeds. Wouldn't we be better off shortening the prison terms of non-violent offenders and spending the money we saved on educating, rehabilitating and training them to live productive lives? When it comes to non-violent drug crimes, shouldn't we be spending the money to provide treatment and vocational skills to allow them to live lives free of drug abuse and the crime to which they resort to be able to afford their next high rather than on draconian sentences destined to destroy their lives and the lives of their children?

When are we going to end the War on Drugs, and in particular, mandatory minimum sentences?

It's not just drug and economic crimes. When are we going to stop allowing prosecutors to have the discretion to try juveniles as adults where they become especially at risk in adult prisons? When are we going to stop mandatory deportation of non-citizens who have been convicted of minor crimes even if they have spent most of their lifetimes in this country paying taxes, working and raising families?

Who is going to care for the children of the incarcerated? For their elderly parents? What did these innocents do to deserve this fate? Inmates have family values too -- as evidenced by the steady stream of relatives that came out in Omaha on a cold Sunday night to put money on their loved one's books. Their family values are as strong as yours or mine.

America is a prison nation. More than two million are currently housed in our state and federal jails. Of those, more than one million are incarcerated for non-violent offenses at a cost of more than $24 billion per year.

It's great that the Democrats have been elected, but there isn't one domestic prisoner issue on their agenda for the new legislative session. I applaud Senators Feingold and Leahy for promising to hold hearings on restoring habeas corpus to the detainees, but it's just not enough.

What I hope for in the coming two years is that Democrats tackle their agenda of ending the War, providing universal health care and saving Social Security as fast as possible, so they can turn their attention from those who are at the center, the middle class, to those who are the most marginalized among us -- the more than 2 million inmates in our prisons.

When that happens, then I'll give my thanks. Today, I'm just feeling guilty that while I'm free to visit my mother in the hospital and then have a warm turkey dinner with friends, millions of others, especially our non-violent inmates, will be separated from those they love and eating processed turkey in cages.

[Cross posted at Huffington Post.]

< O.J. Says He's Innocent, Book Not a Confession | Thanksgiving Anthem: Alice's Restaurant >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: It's a SAFE place to live (4.00 / 1) (#7)
    by Edger on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 12:42:42 PM EST
    We should adopt something similar to Singapore's system of justice. The crime rate there is nearly infantesimal and it's a SAFE place to live.

    Security trumps all.

    And the beat goes on... (3.00 / 1) (#2)
    by jackl2400 on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 08:01:59 AM EST
    Is it because of the Code of Professional Responsibility or practical reasons (retaliation) that you don't put a name and face on "the Government" who opposed the bail request discusssed above?

    Was it "the Government" or was it "Assistant US Attorney Deborah Shmuckatello", who was not basing her decision on the law, justice, reason and compassion but rather role-playing, order-following or career building?

    Thank you for all you do...hopefully we will keep working on these real problems of your clients and millions of others and spend a little less time focusing on celebrity crime (OJ, Aruba Girl, Duke Lacrosse team) and general politics (Plamegate)...leave that to the Smoking Gun and Daily Kos.

    Great Piece (3.00 / 1) (#13)
    by kdog on Fri Nov 24, 2006 at 09:34:46 AM EST
    Thanks as well TL....I wouldn't want to imagine a world without people like you in it.

    raves...not to belittle your loss, but I don't blame the liquor companies for my father's death, it's foolish for you to blame a drug dealer's on your brother's.  Throwing people in cages ain't bringing them back.  As someone who prefers an illegal vice than a legal one, I don't want your compassion as you say, but I would appreciate that you don't advocate for my incarceration...Happy Thanksgiving.


    Reality check please... (1.00 / 1) (#5)
    by ravesnation on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 12:30:04 PM EST
    Forgive me here... I may seem like a cold-hearted, hateful individual but I'm a realist and this post actually offends me!
    I spent the afternoon with a formerly well-to-do businessman, his wife and daughter as they tried to accept that he would be going to prison for a few years for an economic crime he never thought was against the law. The tears, the sadness, the coming to grips with reality -- is it really necessary?

    Absolutely it is necessary. This gentleman you're speaking about has commited a crime. Plain and simple. What about the people this guy hurt by his crimes? If there were any, how would they feel. I see you talking about these prisoners but you fail to mention the victims of the crimes.

    Just because their crime is non-violent, it does not mean that there weren't any victims or harm done in some fashion.

    When are we going to end the War on Drugs, and in particular, mandatory minimum sentences?

    End the war on drugs? Are you serious? My brother died from an overdose. He was addicted to drugs most of his teenage and adult life. He was 32 when he died. I have no compassion for anyone that is involved in drugs in any way, shape, or form. No one is forced into using drugs. It's their decision to get help or not. As far as the dealers go... The sentences are not harsh enough!

    I can't even finish reading your post it is so revolting! I am honestly ashamed to call myself a Democrat when I read something like this.

    I do agree, though, that our justice system needs to be changed. We should adopt something similar to Singapore's system of justice. The crime rate there is nearly infantesimal and it's a SAFE place to live. Guilty until proven innocent.

    You probably should be (5.00 / 1) (#6)
    by Jeralyn on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 12:42:38 PM EST
    reading a different blog.  You won't like it here.

    Parent
    I like it here! (1.00 / 2) (#8)
    by ravesnation on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 12:58:55 PM EST
    I used to post regularly a few years ago... A lot of times I was in agreement with people on here but you are just over the top on this issue. I'm glad you are in the minority. I'm sure any of my fellow Democrats that I know personally would agree with me on this as well as the majority of American's that don't bill their services at 300+ $ an hour. (I'm assuming you're a lawyer.)

    Maybe you should make an attempt to justify your agruement with me instead of wrongfully assuming something about me first?

    I've seen, first hand, the effects of drugs - that one you will never win me over on and, why should anyone have compassion for anyone that's "well-to-do" that's presumably breaking the law to make even more money?

    I'm not trying to be a smarta** here. Really now... Explain to me why your arguement is valid and why we should do the things you're suggesting and don't say because they should be with their families - I won't even patronize that with a response.

    Parent

    Read TalkLeft's About Page (5.00 / 1) (#9)
    by Jeralyn on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 01:07:48 PM EST
    From the about page:

    TalkLeft is not a neutral site. Our mission is to intelligently and thoroughly examine issues, candidates and legislative initiatives as they pertain to constitutional rights, particularly those of persons accused of crime.

    I am not going to debate you or encourage your views on this site.  Your views on drug penalties are as repugnant to me as mine are to you. Again, respectfully, I encourage you to rethink whether you want to comment here.  

    The comment policy is here.

    Parent

    I'll bite. (5.00 / 0) (#10)
    by syinco on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 03:04:15 PM EST
    "Is it really necessary?"
    "Absolutely it is necessary."

    Let's be clear on what we mean by "it"?  Punishment?  Then perhaps.  Let's ignore that intent was apparently absent, and assume that this was properly a crime, and a victimizing one at that.  Then there is clearly a strong (though not absolute) argument that punishment is a necessary response.  But I don't think that was the question posed.  

    I think the question was whether prison for a lengthy term (yes, a few years of incarceration is lengthy) is a necessary response.  There is nothing that suggests to me that this is the only valid response, so I don't follow that this response is absolutely necessary.  To me, it is a sign of complacency, short-sightedness, and absolute lack of compassion to simply conclude that it is.  We have become so assimilated to a culture of incarceration that we appear to have lost the ability to question whether incarceration is the best or even an appropriate response; that we have become inured to what it really means to spend years or even decades behind bars, especially given the problems in our overcrowded and underfunded prison system, further compounds our callous response.

    Yes, callous.  While it is of course not callous to consider victim impact in the course of punishment, it is so to punish without compassion, as you appear quite willing to do.  Punishment in this country is intended to be a response to crime that meets a number of different and sometimes conflicting goals.  Sometimes ameliorating victim impact is one of those goals.  But punishment, including legislating punishment, should be a rational exercise, and while that does afford room for compassion towards actual and potential victims, it cannot, as prescribed, be dominated by those concerns.  

    It also, I believe, necessitates compassion towards the "criminal".  Without compassion - and I do not mean mercy - without compassion for that to which we intend to subject the criminal, i.e. without a full and proper understanding of what it means, especially temporally, to suffer through the imposed punishment, and without consideration of the criminal's situation in the context of culpability, do we not begin to punish arbitrarily, or worse, even maliciously?  If so, then we have failed in our goals to deliver a reasoned response to the crime.  This failure is particularly and grossly manifest in the political grandstanding that has led to longer and more widespread sentencing in recent years.  Compassion towards the criminal, at least in this sense, is a necessary element of most any rational sentencing policy that aims to do more than appease frustration or satiate bloodlust.

    As for the War on Drugs - there's too much to discuss to try and elaborate a position.  But in the context of your comment, let me just suggest that a more rehabilitative approach and the question of low-level versus high-level dealers, particularly the differentiating environments and motivations that encourage each, are two of many aspects worth more consideration before taking any absolute position on this issue.  I think the only extremist position on this issue is one of closed-mindedness.  

    I am sorry for the loss of your brother.  Drugs are a problem, and I would that we can find ways so that others do not pay the price you and your brother have paid.

    Happy Thanksgiving.

    Parent

    You Got It Easy, Jeralyn (none / 0) (#1)
    by terry hallinan on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 03:47:50 AM EST
    When I visited the maximum security prison, I visited a friend who will never get out.  

    Oh some think he will but he won't.  He knows it too but he can't say it.  When hope is lost, there is nothing left.

    The government has too much to lose.

    Thank you for what you do.  I know the effort has to be heartbreaking.  Few of us could take on such a task.  I surely couldn't.

    Happy Thanksgiving to you especially and hope there are better Thanksgivings for those you care so much about.

    All I can offer you is that there are some worse off. A shabby gift for sure but it is all I have to give.

    I give thanks there are people like you, Jeralyn. It makes me know the world is not all bad.  

    Best,  Terry

    Happy Thanksgiving Jeralyn (none / 0) (#3)
    by Edger on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 08:40:32 AM EST
    You have the desire and the ability and the motivation to to help people you see needing help, and you try in your way to make the world a better place. Being upbeat without those things would be rather shallow. Nearly empty, I think.

    Thanks. For being you.

    Thanks from yet another reader n/t (none / 0) (#4)
    by janinsanfran on Thu Nov 23, 2006 at 08:48:48 AM EST