home

Evangelical Leaders Downplay Haggard's Importance

Here comes the dump on Pastor Ted Haggard:

Pat Robertson:

"We're sad to see any evangelical leader fall," the Rev. Pat Robertson said on his television show, "The 700 Club." But, he added, it "just isn't true" that the NAE represents 30 million churchgoers, as the association claims.

"We can't get their financial data. I think it's because they have very little money and very little influence," Robertson said.

Jerry Falwell:

The Rev. Jerry Falwell, speaking Thursday night on CNN, said Haggard "doesn't really lead the movement. He's president of an association that's very loose-knit . . . and no one has looked to them for leadership."

Jealousy and running for cover. I suspect Falwell and Robertson never liked Haggard to begin with. He was far too moderate for their brand of evangelicalism. He was the up and comer and they are the old guard whose dynasties are fading.

Haggard is an environmentalist who wanted the church to support global warming. He's a civil libertarian. While he opposed gay marriage, he refused to take a position on Referendum I (domestic partnership rights) on the Colorado ballot this year, saying the church and the law should stay separate on civil liberties issues. He supported the Supreme Court's decision in Lawrence v. Texas. He thought the law should stay out of people's bedrooms. When Amendment 2 was on the Colorado ballot, which would have prevented cities from enacting ordinances protecting gays, he opposed it. He wanted the church to get involved in Darfur.

Was Haggart a hyprocrite on homosexuality? Yes. But he's no Falwell or Robertson.

< Saudi Court Sentences Victim of Gang Rape to 90 Lashes | Is Tennessee the Key to Control of the Senate? >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Here in Denver. . . (none / 0) (#1)
    by Cugel on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 01:10:42 AM EST
    I just voted in early voting. HUGE line, but everything went smoothly.

    It's difficult to imagine Paccione winning her race. The level of outrageous smear ads I've seen against her is simply amazing and the people out in eastern Colo. are hard core Repugs who gave Bush 60% approval in 2004.

    But, based on the polling it might not have even been a good thing for Musgrave to do all the negative advertising. Independents are not liking it at all.

    Paccione appears in her ad that just states truthfully that Mugsgrave says that her anti-gay marriage initiative is more important than the war in Iraq, more important than anything, including drought relief for her district. It's an effective ad. I would be convinced if I were an indy, but I long ago gave up thinking that logic would sway Colo. conservatives in any election. They are just hopeless for the most part - voting on insane issues like whether Bush "was a good christian man" as if that were a substitute for intelligent leadership.

    Oh, well, I imagine Bush is here because his presence will rally the base voters and give Musgrave at least 2 or 3 points on election day among the right-tards out on the plains.

    The fact that the district is in play at all simply means that Iraq is poison everywhere this year.

    Missing the point on Pastor Haggard (none / 0) (#14)
    by Hunter80904 on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 06:05:53 PM EST

    You guys are missing the story here...  So, Ted's gay, No real surprise there... He uses Meth and pays for Gay hookers... That all well and good too...

    The real story here people is that this guy is tightly tied to several Colorado Politicians running for reelection... Lets start with Kyle Fisk,  Mr. Fisk (otherwise known as Pastor Kyle Fisk of the New Life Church) is running for the Colorado State House of Representatives in House District 18.  Doug Lamborn is running for the US Congress in Colorado Congressional District 5 and is also a very close friend and ally (Probably former now) of Pastor Haggard.  Additionally, Bob Beauprez running for Governor and Marilynn Musgrave running for US congress in CD 4 are all tightly tied to Pastor Haggard, Focus on the Family and their political machines.  None of these guys will comment on their ties to Pastor Haggard and it high time this was exposed...

    Lets go people, Can some one please get this story out...

    Lost in Colorado Springs


    Parent

    Good background article on Haggard (none / 0) (#2)
    by theologicus on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 09:15:05 AM EST
    Soldiers of Christ
    By Jeff Sharlet

    Inside America's most powerful megachurch with Pastor Ted Haggard
    Harper's magazine
    May 2005

    www.harpers.org/SoldiersOfChrist-20061103288348488.html

    Many creepy details.


    Peace (none / 0) (#3)
    by jimakaPPJ on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 10:50:52 AM EST
    I haven't paid much attention to this story, don't really care that much either way.

    But I wonder why I never see a simple comment that says, "We feel for him, his family, friends and those he preached to. May God grant them understanding and peace. And may he receive the help he needs."

    Parent

    But, but... (none / 0) (#4)
    by Repack Rider on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 11:17:50 AM EST
    I wonder why I never see a simple comment that says, "We feel for him, his family, friends and those he preached to. May God grant them understanding and peace. And may he receive the help he needs."

    Once a guy has rubbed YOUR "sinful ways" in your face for a decade or two, he gets no mercy when it turns out that he is a far worse exampe of sinfulness than any of the people he harangued.

    When a guy uses his "moral authority" to influence elections, and then turns out to have no moral authority whatever, he deserves all the condemnation available.

    If Al Sharpton was found to have a drug habit and a gay lover, do you REALLY think the GOP would ignore it?

    Please.

    How much of a hypocrite would a person have to be before it offended you?  I'm sorry, I meant, how much of a hypocrite would a REPUBLICAN have to be...?

    Parent

    But, but... but... (none / 0) (#5)
    by Edger on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 11:27:01 AM EST
    He's a 'social liberal' Repack. Heh. He 'feels' for Haggard. :-\

    Parent
    Better than them. (none / 0) (#18)
    by jimakaPPJ on Sun Nov 05, 2006 at 07:31:27 PM EST
    RePack - Leave it to the Left to politicalize every thing.

    My comment stands. If you can't rise above your enemies, what are you?

    Before you asnwer, remember the many comments made by the Left saying the US shouldn't do this or that because we must be better than them.

    Doesn't look like you can make the grade.

    Parent

    And also with you (none / 0) (#6)
    by theologicus on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 11:39:26 AM EST
    I agree of course with the poker player's simple comment.

    He never sees such comments but they're out there,  I've seen more than one.

    I also agree with his respondents.

    By the way, Steve Soto says that when Haggard admitted to buying meth, he admitted to a felony.  Is that correct?

    Parent

    Missing the point on Pastor Haggard (none / 0) (#16)
    by Hunter80904 on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 06:09:56 PM EST

    You guys are missing the story here...  So, Ted's gay, No real surprise there... He uses Meth and pays for Gay hookers... That all well and good too...

    The real story here people is that this guy is tightly tied to several Colorado Politicians running for election... Lets start with Kyle Fisk,  Mr. Fisk (otherwise known as Pastor Kyle Fisk of the New Life Church) is running for the Colorado State House of Representatives in House District 18.  Doug Lamborn is running for the US Congress in Colorado Congressional District 5 and is also a very close friend and ally (Probably former now) of Pastor Haggard.  Additionally, Bob Beauprez running for Governor and Marilynn Musgrave running for US congress in CD 4 are all tightly tied to Pastor Haggard, Focus on the Family and their political machines.  None of these guys will comment on their ties to Pastor Haggard  AND THE LOCAL RIGHT WING PRESS IS SURPRESSING THE STORY. Its high time this was exposed...  

    Lets go people, Can some one please get this story out...


    Parent

    Feel for whom? (none / 0) (#7)
    by Kitt on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 12:34:39 PM EST
    Feel for Haggard? Because he has, as have others, slung their moral authority/superiority in our faces  with all kinds of slanted claims of 'god on their side.' No, I don't feel sorry, emphathy or anything right now for Haggard.

    The ones I do feel for are those he has duped and betrayed, specifically his wife. In passing as I was leaving the house last night I saw a bit where Haggard was talking to a reporter, and his wife was in the car. I watched his face, his eyes when he answered and how they automatically flicked to her. The reporter asked him a question, his wife was watching the reported & the way she turned her head toward Haggard, you just knew she dreaded his answer. Which is why his eyes flicked to her. It's her....no matter what he's done: it's her & he knows it. She is the key for him.

    The thing with Haggard and Jeralyn hit square on the head, he was more moderate (if that's possible as a rabid evangelical) than Dobson, Falwell, Parsley, Perkins or any of those are or want.

    Missing the point on Pastor Haggard (none / 0) (#15)
    by Hunter80904 on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 06:07:03 PM EST
    Calling all Bloggers...

    You guys are missing the story here...  So, Ted's gay, No real surprise there... He uses Meth and pays for Gay hookers... That all well and good too...

    The real story here people is that this guy is tightly tied to several Colorado Politicians running for election... Lets start with Kyle Fisk,  Mr. Fisk (otherwise known as Pastor Kyle Fisk of the New Life Church) is running for the Colorado State House of Representatives in House District 18.  Doug Lamborn is running for the US Congress in Colorado Congressional District 5 and is also a very close friend and ally (Probably former now) of Pastor Haggard.  Additionally, Bob Beauprez running for Governor and Marilynn Musgrave running for US congress in CD 4 are all tightly tied to Pastor Haggard, Focus on the Family and their political machines.  None of these guys will comment on their ties to Pastor Haggard and it high time this was exposed...  

    Lets go people, Can some one please get this story out...

    Lost in Colorado Springs

    Parent

    Haggard article (none / 0) (#8)
    by sarcastic unnamed one on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 02:06:16 PM EST
    fwiw, today's (Saturday) LA Times has an article on Haggard. I don't have an online subscription, only hard copy, so I can't link or cut and paste it here.

    Anyway, they describe Haggard basically as a very much a moderate on homosexuality and many other things evangelical.

    For instance, if I remember the article correctly, he supported the (I assume recent) Texas decision to srike down their anti-sodomy laws, among other relatively pro-gay statements/actions.

    He also seems to feel that global warming is a bigger issue than gays in direct contrast to, and conflict with, much of the evangelical leadership, if that means anything.

    Anyway, the Times doesn't seem to think he's quite the ogre some here have portrayed him as, although I'm sure that's very much in the eyes of the beholder...

    Get Facts Straight (none / 0) (#9)
    by glanton on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 02:19:57 PM EST
    he supported the (I assume recent) Texas decision to srike down their anti-sodomy laws, among other relatively pro-gay statements/actions.

    Sarcasmo as usual the thrust of your argument is sound--Haggard's not quite the Ogre, after all, that many liberals in their rabid frustration have made him out to be.  But please remember that it was the United States Supreme Court (pre Roberts and Alito) that wrote Lawrence v Texas, which struck down sodomy laws in Texas.  Texas being the benighted loser.  

    The idea that Texas voters would themselves do something pro civil liberties really shouldn't be spread among civilized readers, sarcasmo, expeically by someone sensible like you.

    Unless like Pat Buchana you count standing up for fanatics running gun compounds a pro civil liberties stance.  In which case, toss Texans a bone.

    Straight (per se) facts (none / 0) (#10)
    by sarcastic unnamed one on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 02:48:52 PM EST
    But please remember that it was the United States Supreme Court (pre Roberts and Alito) that wrote Lawrence v Texas, which struck down sodomy laws in Texas.

    Thanks, gman. No misinformation intended.

    Parent

    Haggard (none / 0) (#11)
    by Dadler on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 03:36:07 PM EST
    I have seen plenty of clips of the guy to understand that, in many respects, he is indeed an "ogre".  I've heard the global warming angle before, which is dandy, but has no bearing on the completely fraudulent nature of his moralizing and leadership.  He is a complete fraud.  The entire basis of his public being is revealed as nothing more than misprojected self-hatred.  If he shows me he's a sentient being in the near future, talks about how full of sh*t he's been, how he never should've so blithely condemned other people from the pulpit, people who were merely struggling with human problems like he was, how he's had to come to terms with who he really IS...then maybe I'll change my tune.  As it is, he's just Rush Limbaugh with a mildly green thumb.  So full of it it's a wonder he can breathe.

    Here's the LAT article (none / 0) (#12)
    by theologicus on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 03:52:37 PM EST
    Just a massage, pastor says
    Ted Haggard, who led a national evangelical group, says he also bought meth from the gay prostitute.
    By Stephanie Simon, Times Staff Writer
    November 4, 2006

    www.latimes.com/news/printedition/la-na-haggard4nov04,1,56646.story

    ...Though Haggard has spoken out on abortion and same-sex marriage from time to time, he is less fiery on those topics than many of his colleagues are. He has pushed, instead, for a broader concept of biblical values: He wants evangelicals to be more involved in protecting the environment and helping the poor.

    Haggard has not joined other evangelicals in campaigning against a Colorado initiative to provide domestic partnership benefits to same-sex couples. He also stood out among conservative preachers for publicly praising a 2003 Supreme Court decision that struck down a Texas anti-sodomy law. ...

    ...Haggard's push for action on global warming raised hackles among powerful leaders on the religious right. With Haggard discredited, those leaders may be able to swing the focus back to issues such as abortion. Or the evangelical movement -- a solid GOP bloc over several election cycles -- could splinter.

    "This could have quite profound implications for how evangelicals [affect] politics in the future," Green said, "long after we've forgotten the results of this coming election."

    The Harper's article mentioned above, which goes much deeper, is recommended.

    Doesn't matter now - he's out (none / 0) (#13)
    by Kitt on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 05:13:00 PM EST
    Ted Haggard was fired today from his pastorship. It's on CNN - bright yellow box. John @ Americablog has a letter issued from the church as well.

    The Harper's article is a good one; I read it when it first came out.


    All right, Hunter (none / 0) (#17)
    by Kitt on Sat Nov 04, 2006 at 08:13:29 PM EST
    We get your point....

    You guys are missing the story here...  So, Ted's gay, No real surprise there... He uses Meth and pays for Gay hookers... That all well and good too..
    .

    And we're not missing the point or the story. Over at Red State, there's the claim that they had never heard of Ted Haggard. They're either liars or they are not as politically savvy as they like to claim.

    I, for one, know about all these scumballs coming out of Colorado Springs and their little theocratic 'kingdom' and now one giant has come crashing down.