Who Can Assert Executive Privilege?
Update [2007-7-8 21:16:18 by Big Tent Democrat]: On the merits of the executive privilege claim, let me point you to the great analysis of Jack Balkin.
This seems an obvious answer and it is - only the President can assert executive privilege. The context here is the statement by former White House staffer Sara Taylor's lawyer that:
Ms. Taylor expects to receive a letter from [White House Counsel Fred] Fielding on behalf of the President directing her not to comply with the Senate’s subpoena. . . . Absent the direction from the White House, Ms. Taylor would testify without hesitation before the Senate Judiciary Committee. . . [Taylor] faces two untenable choices. She can follow the President’s direction and face the possibility of a contempt sanction by the Senate . . .
Actually, Ms. Taylor has no LEGAL choice in the matter. Executive privilege is not hers to assert. If the White House wishes to assert executive privilege, it must seek a court order quashing the Congressional subpoena on such grounds. The President has NO LEGAL POWER over Ms. Taylor. A Congressional subpoena is binding on Ms. Taylor unless quashed. To coin a phrase, Ms. Taylor has no STANDING to claim executive privilege.
< The Congressional Subpoena Power: How It Is Enforced | Bush Asserts Executive Privilege: How Will Congress Respond? > |