Chris writes:
1. Self-identification does not mesh with policy preference
Ideological self-identification does not accurately place Americans into categories representing coherent worldviews. This is a point that the Pew survey itself makes, though it has received less attention than the topline numbers:
Still, ideological labels do not always predict opinions about key policy issues. For example, about half of Americans who describe their political views as conservative say that all (24%) or some (27%) of the tax cuts passed under George W. Bush should be repealed. More than four-in-ten conservatives (43%) say that abortion should be legal in some or all cases. On the other hand, nearly half of self-described liberals (49%) favor more offshore drilling for oil and gas in U.S. waters.
Just because someone describes him or herself as a liberal, moderate or a conservative, does not mean that person actually is a liberal, a moderate or a conservative.
Chris misses the point I think. "Moderate" now means Democrat on the issues and at the voting booth. This is a good thing. I will drag out my old saw from my first Talk Left post in 2006:
And that is FDR's lesson for Obama. Politics is not a battle for the middle. It is a battle for defining the terms of the political debate. It is a battle to be able to say what is the middle.
The Democratic agenda is the middle. We won.
Speaking for me only