Was The Message Of The Tea Parties Secession, States' Rights and Racism?
Posted on Thu Apr 16, 2009 at 10:12:48 AM EST
Tags: (all tags)
I consciously avoided denigrating the Tea Parties before because I thought the message, muddled as it was, as wrong as it was and as hypocritical as it was coming from Bush deadenders, it was a legitimate expression of a point of view. Texas Governor Rick Perry's secession threat changes that. Consider the comments thread of this eminently sensible post from Allah Pundit:
[Rick Perry's statements on secession were] [s]imply awful, whether as a convenient distraction for the media from the tea parties or as a brush for them to tar the protests as motivated by crackpot neo-confederate sentiments.
The Tea Partiers have tarred themselves. And consider the reaction to Allah Pundit's rationality:
Texas was an independent nation before it was a state. it was not conqured or bought. I last I checked you can withdrawl from treaties… I am not a traitor. I have served this country for 11 years and have gone on 3 deployments since 9/11. I do not view sucession as a good idea… but, as I learn more about our fouding fathers, I see why people view it as a viable option. My “rights” do not come from government. They come from god. government can only take (or try to take) them from me. BadBrad on April 16, 2009 at 7:15 AM
At this point Americans have three options, those being leave, stay and fight, or stay and take one in the pooper like a Jetboy on prom night. Well look at that! Texans want to fight! What a shock! And look there! AllahP is taking a backdoor delivery! Also a shock! /already gone TMK on April 16, 2009 at 7:20 AM
Ron White: In Texas we have the death penalty, and WE USE IT! If you come to Texas and kill somebody, we will kill you back! radiofreevillage, We have an express lane for execution in Texas and would be more than happy to put your smart-ass at the front on that line!! try again later on April 16, 2009 at 8:17 AM
Unfortunately tethered to slavery… Secession was a legitimate option when Massachusetts threatened it and when SC, AL, etc. acted on it. You need to read the case for secession. Jefferson Davis, et al, believed that they were saving the Constitution. They were originalists. Of course, you can’t mention this absolute right championed by Jefferson and the Founders without being tagged a racist… but that is just a red herring. People can secede for the SAKE of the Constitution. Secession can be seen as upholding and the defending the Constitution of the United States from domestic enemies. mankai on April 16, 2009 at 8:25 AM
The Founders were not “traitors,” they argued that the King and the people had a social contract… when a King becomes a tyrant he breaks the contract binding his subjects to him. I realize that we elected our “King,” but when Jefferson spoke/wrote of a people’s right (duty?) to revolt, he didn’t make that distinction. The Second Amendment was proposed in part as a rememdy against tyranny UNDER THE CONSTITUTION. We defend the right of the citizenry to be armed as a defense against an oppressive federal government… so we can assume that the Founders could imagine a scenario whereby asserting that right would not be akin to “treason”… rather it would be the greatest act of patriotism. mankai on April 16, 2009 at 8:32 AM
Political agendas determine the findings published. Until you read the documents yourself, Allahpundit, you remain ignorant. Recall your blame on Joe Wurzelbacher, apprenticed employee of a certified and registered plumber. Your thread then stated that Joe was breaking the law. Prick. maverick muse on April 16, 2009 at 8:44 AM
Secession failed in the civil war. But does that mean it’s unconstitutional? Do states not have the RIGHT to secede? If, say, 66% of the people in a state voted to secede, would they have the right to do so? If not, then doesn’t that really mean the Federal government IS the ultimate authority in this nation? hawksruleva on April 16, 2009 at 9:05 AM
As for the racism message, Matt Yglesias covers the significant number of instances at the Tea Parties.
In the end, it turns out the message of the Tea Parties is the one that has turned the Republican Party into the Southern white party it now is. This is just more of the same.
Speaking for me only
< Prison Consultant Convicted of Impersonating Lawyer | Colorado Considers Sweeping Sentencing Reform > |