home

The Double Standard on Leakers

Murray Waas has a new article in the National Journal asking, Is There a Double Standard on Leakers? The answer is yes.

Murray reports that Sen. Pat Roberts, who praised the CIA's firing of an agent who reportedly disclosed classified information to WaPo reporter Dana Priest for an article on CIA secret prisons, has himself been a leaker.

Roberts now:

"[T]hose who leak classified information not only risk the disclosure of intelligence sources and methods, but also expose the brave men and women of the intelligence community to greater danger. Clearly, those guilty of improperly disclosing classified information should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law."

Roberts three years ago:

On the eve of the invasion of Iraq, Roberts himself was involved in disclosing sensitive intelligence information that, according to four former senior intelligence officers, impaired efforts to capture Saddam Hussein and potentially threatened the lives of Iraqis who were spying for the United States.

....The former intelligence officials said in interviews that Roberts was never held accountable for his comments, which bore directly on the issue of intelligence-gathering sources and methods, and revealed that Iraqis close to Hussein were probably talking to the United States. These former officials contrasted the Roberts case with last week's firing of CIA officer Mary O. McCarthy, as examples of how rank and file intelligence professionals now have much to fear from legitimate and even inadvertent contacts with journalists, while senior executive branch officials and members of Congress are almost never held accountable when they seriously breach national security through leaks of information.

As for fired agent Mary McCarthy, her lawyer Ty Cobb Tuesday again denied she was the source of the secret prison leaks, adding:

Noting that McCarthy was only ten days short of retirement, Cobb said: "Her hope had been to leave with her dignity and reputation intact, which obviously did not happen."

Following McCarthy's firing, Pat Roberts has this to say:

Roberts said on Friday that he was "pleased that the Central Intelligence Agency has identified the source of certain unauthorized disclosures, and I hope that the Agency, and the Community as a whole, will continue to vigorously investigate other outstanding leak cases."

Right back at you, Senator Roberts.