home

Jamaica Wants to Bring Back Hangings

This is a very interesting article about the growing hostility of Jamaicans to the British Justice System with which it is entwined. The death penalty lies at the center of the disharmony, but as you'll see, it's Jamaica, not Britain, that wants to hold onto the archaic past.

The anatagonism began spreading after a Jamaican who was sentenced to death row for killing a policeman had his conviction overturned by Britain.

Poor, young and idle, Randall Dixon was one of the usual suspects when Det. Cpl. Phillip Gordon ended up dead in a chaotic firefight between four bank robbers and four policemen. Despite witness testimony that Dixon wasn't involved in the 1996 Western Union Bank robbery, he was arrested, tried, convicted and sentenced to die by hanging.

Dixon, now 37, has had his sentence struck down by the Privy Council in London on appeal because videotape from security cameras — suppressed by police for the last seven years — proved he wasn't there.

You would think the Jamaicans would be pleased that one of their own who turned out to be innocent was spared the ultimate penalty, right? Wrong.

That [ruling] might be expected to make Jamaicans question their judicial system, which lawyers and human rights advocates here say is so flawed that courts have repeatedly condemned innocents to the gallows. Instead, the ruling angered many Jamaicans. They see the high court in faraway London as a vestige of colonial rule trying to impose its anti-death-penalty values on this eye-for-an-eye Caribbean culture.

82% of Jamaicans support the death penalty. They have a "horrific murder rate." Obviously, the death penalty is not serving as a deterrent here.

Jamaicans formally joined the Caribbean Court of Justice in June. The Court will serve as a "court of last resort" for 14 island countries. Prime Minister P.J. Patterson successfully got the backing of many Jamaicans for the Court, by promising a "resumption of of hangings over the objections of the Privy Council"--and "made the threat of execution the cornerstone of a new anti-crime program. Noting the clear majority in favor of capital punishment, Patterson vowed that "we intend to heed the voice of the people."

< Corruption Alleged at Customs | Around the Bloggerhood >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort: