home

Molestation Abuse Hysteria

What happens to children who falsely accuse adults of sexual abuse when they grow up? Some, like Ed Sampley, try to make amends. Sampley was one of five kids who accused John Stoll, then a 41 year old carpenter of sexual abuse. Stoll got 40 years in jail.

Last January, Sampley and three other former accusers returned to the courthouse where they had testified against Stoll. This time they came to say Stoll never molested them. They are in their late 20's now. They have jobs in construction, car repair, sales. A couple of them have children about the same age as they were when they testified. Although most of the boys drifted apart after the trial, their life stories echo with similarities. Each of them said he always knew the truth -- that Stoll had never touched them. Each said that he felt pressured by the investigators to describe sex acts. A fifth accuser isn't sure what happened all those years ago but has no memory of being molested.

The article, in Sunday's New York Times magazine, is seven pages. Unfortunately, the hysteria may be cyclical.

...discredited child-sex rings like McMartin actually may not be a bogeyman of the past. Some parents, therapists and child-protection professionals continue to believe ritual sex abuse took place at McMartin preschool. ''In 10 to 15 years, there will be an attempt to rehabilitate the ritual abuse scare,'' [Univ. of Texas psychologist Wood says. ''You can bet on it.''

Sampley still feels guilt over his false testimony:

Though Sampley clearly helped win Stoll's release by recanting his testimony, it hasn't purged the past. It hasn't erased his feelings of guilt for telling investigators what he thought they wanted to hear. It hasn't quieted his questions about why he did it. And it doesn't end his unease around strangers' children. ''I'll never coach Little League,'' he says. Recently, he was at a playground with his daughter when a kid in the next swing asked Sampley to give him a push. ''I said no. It just made me uncomfortable.''

As to Stoll:

Stoll, who now lives in the San Jose guesthouse of two of his lawyers while he figures out how to spend the rest of his life, telephones Sampley and some of the other kids every once in a while. There is something fatherly in his voice when Stoll talks about the boys -- as if they were as much victims as he was. ''I worry about them,'' he says. ''It seems to me they're all struggling in one way or another.''

< Details of Saddam's Confinement | Sunday Reading >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Witch Hunt-Kern Molestion Hysteria (none / 0) (#1)
    by PJS on Mon Oct 23, 2006 at 10:46:25 PM EST
    Filmmakers are in production on a documentary about the molestation hysteria that gripped Bakersfield in the early 80s. The film will detail a modern day unravelling of the justice system, and the toll that wrongful convictions take on the lives of victims and their families. More info is available at http://www.luckyexitfilms.com.

    For those who haven't heard about this episode, the Kern County's DA office falsely accused and convicted dozens of working class people of child molestation in the 1980s. Most guilty verdicts were based on testimony of children, who were coerced into saying their parents molested them by county social workers and sheriff's deputies.

    Ed Jagels, the DA that presided over the molestation hysteria, and the subsequent reversal of dozens of guilty verdicts, has recently returned to the headlines in Bakersfield by lashing out at the Bakersfield Californian newspaper, posting his critique of the paper's coverage on the District Attorney's public website. Interesting use of taxpayer resources.

    His first column entitled 'Every Lie They Print':
    http://www.co.kern.ca.us/da/newsAnnounce.asp