home

Blogger Reaction to Third Debate

Here's the transcript of tonight's debate.

Now, reaction from the blogosphere:

Josh Marshall:

Kerry looked more presidential than the president. I don't know how else to put it. He seemed collected and forceful through the whole thing. The president, meanwhile, seemed excitable, edgy and sometimes ungrounded. Again and again with the banging the table. Perhaps after one question you can get away with a cocky look of sarcastic disbelief after your opponent stops talking. But not every other time.

Another point struck me as similar to the first debate, very similar. Kerry controlled the tempo of the evening. He kept the president on the defensive. He landed his key points about the budget deficit and the president's avoidance of the job issue several times. On health care there was more of a tussle. But I don't think the president framed the evening in the way he and his advisors wanted -- defining Kerry as an out-of-the-mainstream liberal. He did better at that in debate number two than he did tonight.

Oliver Willis:

I give it to Kerry simply because his ideas don't suck, and he can MAKE COMPLETE FRICKIN' SENTENCES and the fact that the president can't talk without making big giant lies...."What have you learned from your wife?" Why is that question in a presidential debate? Not even relevant. And Bush on his wife: she tells me to stand up straight, talk right -- is she his mom?

Tapped (Mark Goldberg)

LOOK AT MOTHER NATURE ON THE RUN. Not a single question about the environment. Not one mention of the Bush administration's decision to rescind the cap and trade restrictions on mercury; not one mention of Kyoto; not a single, solitary word spoken on the Orwellian Clear Skies Initiative or the chronic asthma that’s plaguing young black children in our cities; not one mention of global warming, MTBE in our water, or renewable resources. But, thanks to Bob Schieffer, at least we know that George W. Bush loves his wife and John Kerry his mother.

[I'd add, not a single question about the death penalty.]

Chris Bowers at MyDD:

With the polls, both telephone and Internet, all showing sweeping wins for Kerry, and with the pundits calling either a draw or a Kerry victory, there is now little doubt that Kerry won not only this debate, but all three debates. Every time, Kerry crushed Bush among independents and undecideds. Every time the enthusiasm of the left wing netroots was greater than that of our equally sized right wing adversaries.

< Debate: Who Won? | Martha Stewart Shopping for Publisher for 'Prison Diary' >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft