home

Enron Documentary to Open Next Week

The acclaimed documentary Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room is set to open Wednesday in Houston to an invitation-only audience. The film, which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival in January, opens to the public nationwide on April 29. The film is based on the book "The Smartest Guys in the Room," by two writers for Fortune Magazine Bethany McLean and Peter Elkind, both of whom appear throughout the film.

I watched the film this week. It's very well done and worth viewing. Of course, it's also entirely one sided, demonizing all but the whistle blowers, Barbara Boxer and curiously, Gray Davis.

Statements by principals Ken Lay and Jeff Skilling, at press conferences, company meetings and before Congress, are interlaced with descriptive commentary by former employees Amanda Martin, Sherron Watkins and others, and mixed with a cool sound track and snippets from pop culture. The film's goal is to establish that Enron was a human tragedy, not just a numbers tragedy.

The first half of the film concentrates on Jeff Skilling with plenty of bashing. There's also a slam of former CEO Lou Pi who had a major fascination with strippers. According to former employees, Pi left Enron after getting a divorce and marrying his stripper girlfriend, making $250 million. It reports he has became the second largest landowner in Colorado.

There are scenes showing the close connection between both GW and his father and Ken Lay. It's comical to watch Alan Greenspan giving an award to Ken Lay.

The sound track is very eclectic. Billie Holliday to Marilyn Manson. There are plenty of visuals, from skydivers to the Simpsons.

The second half of the film attacks Andy Fastow, who is introduced by the Traffic song, "Dear Mr. Fantasy," while images of a magician with a black hat and rabbits fill the screen. There's the obligatory shots of Fastow taking the Fifth and his perp walk.

The section on the California energy crisis is well done. It also makes the lower level Enron traders look terrible. They'd rob a corpse. Gray Davis is portrayed as a victim of Bush and Cheney, who in turn come across as pathetic for their inaction and their ties to Enron and Lay. There are scenes from the Gray Davis - Arnold Schwarzenegger campaign, with Jay Leno introducing Arnold after his win.

The film tries to make the point that Enron is symbolic of a larger failure of moral culture in the country. "Synergistic corruption" is one phrase used. It suggests that like the Enron traders, we all lose our moral compass once we arrive at work. I don't buy it. Enron is about accounting fraud and employee greed. My question after watching the film is how and why did Enron, which truly was the Emperor with No Clothes, escape the scrutiny of business reporters, market analysts and institutional investors for so long? They seem to have been asleep at the switch.

The film succeeds in explaining the complex stock, energy and accounting issues in terms you can understand. It's very watchable and moves fast. It pushes your emotional buttons and it's hard not to have a visceral disgust for Ken Lay. But it overdoes it at times. I thought The Simpson's scene crossed the line into farce. The maudlin tone at the end seems overly melodramatic and the multiple references to the Titanic seem trite.

Other gripes: The final segment on the fall of Enron and its leaders is too moralistic for my taste. They even bring in a Priest to comment about losing one's soul. The employees provide amateur psychoanalysis of their former bosses - but they all have axes to grind and no qualifications in this area.

Jeff Skilling, Ken Lay and Richard Causey go on trial in January. Their defenses to the criminal charges, which I would think are discernible from court pleadings, are not mentioned in the film.

By all means, see the movie. It's very well done. But by all means, remember, it is the equivalent of the Government's opening statement and the real trial takes place in the courtroom, not on a movie screen.

You can watch trailers here and here. There's even an official weblog here.

  

< Michael Jackson: Accuser's Mother Admits Lying Under Oath | New Report on Extraordinary Rendition >
  • The Online Magazine with Liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news

  • Contribute To TalkLeft


  • Display: Sort:
    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#1)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Apr 16, 2005 at 12:47:21 PM EST
    Thanks for this report. Has anyone read the new book on Enron by Kurt Eichenwald (I forget what its called)? If so, how was it? I read his book, "The Informant," on the Archer Daniels Midland antitrust scandal. He has a gift for making events come alive.

    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#2)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Apr 16, 2005 at 12:53:59 PM EST
    Spainster, there's a link to it at the end of this post. If you buy it through the link, TalkLeft gets a buck or so.

    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#3)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Apr 16, 2005 at 08:46:36 PM EST
    Here's a story that can't get any legs. Arnold Schwarzenegger met with Ken Lay in May 2001, just as energy traders were shutting down generators to rip off "Grandma Millie," jamming electricity bills "right up her a—for f-----g $250 a megawatt hour." Meanwhile, Gray Davis opens a $9 billion law suit against Enron to recoup its ill-gotten gains. Schwarznegger boots Gray Davis out of office, and...poof...no more law suit!

    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#4)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sat Apr 16, 2005 at 09:00:38 PM EST
    I thought the soundtrack was spectacular.

    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#5)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sun Apr 17, 2005 at 12:53:51 PM EST
    It will be one more government coverup for the rich.

    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#6)
    by Talkleft Visitor on Sun Apr 17, 2005 at 03:12:27 PM EST
    Curiously? Gray Davis was legally elected, unlike the Austrian Vote-Fraud, Immigration-Fraud, serial sex offender, and Karl Rove co-conspirator. And he fought ENRON-Bush face-to-face, which is something to be proud of. Resistance to tyranny is love of God. Schroeder, that lawsuit was by Bustamante, would have closed the budget deficit (which Schw. and the media lied about) and now has been whittled down to $6 B. The eventual settlement will be $750,000 and change, payable directly into Ken Lay's account -- though the state will have to allow the logging out of Sequoia Nat'l Park, and a few other jewels, as well as allowing more oil derricks in the Santa Barbara Channel -- stuff like that. Nothing to worry about.

    Re: Enron Documentary to Open Next Week (none / 0) (#7)
    by kdog on Mon Apr 18, 2005 at 07:53:39 AM EST
    I'm still hoping Ken Lay and the boys run into a little street justice in a back alley somewhere.